If you're going to be in mud much, and still sticking with an AT tire, i'd go with the duratracs. I recently changed to 285/75/16 Duratracs, and am very happy with their off road performance so far. Though it does take a bit of wheel spin to clear them, they do not clog up nearly as much as say a BFG AT, which become slicks pretty quickly. I do have one tire that I think is out of round, which is worth mentioning, because I've read quite a few reports about this issue with this tire. Going to be in contact with DT about this soon. I'm not totally confident in their sidewall strength, but so far so good.