Fishrising
Observer
I went through the same thing you are going though several months ago. Looked at every tire on your list and then some. I went with the BFG KO2s in 34 x 10.5. They are far better than the previous generation on all surfaces IMO (which I had on my previous Jeep in 285/70/17) and served me well in Moab this year. Love them. I think I paid $280 each at Discount Tire. I get the same MPG as I did with the stock tires and they are way more quite.
You might check this out, a good review of the tires in this size (great blog too)
http://theroadchoseme.com/tire-selection-bfgoodrich-ko2-all-terrain
What lift is on your rig? Sorry on tapatalk, so if it's in your signature, my apologies, I'll see it when I get on a real computer...