Yeah, good question, and I wish I had the answer. Coyote Flat is known for eating tires, and it has happened to me whether I have been running street pressure (33psi) or my more typical 'off-road' pressure of 22psi. The car isn't too heavy - only running my camping gear, recovery gear, and an awning (no RTT, etc. - I sleep in the back). That said, it's a GC, so not exactly a light vehicle... ;-).
Will 17" wheels fit on your Jeep?
I wish! But sadly no - because of my brakes, I can't go below a 18" tire.
The thing is, your Grand Cherokee is a car and you're trying to get truck tires to fit it
Very true - and as mentioned, I'm definitely not told on getting LT tires. I like the idea of a stronger side wall, but for most other driving LTs wouldn't be preferable and they're pretty overkill for a GC.
I'll probably wait around a little to see if any new tires come out, but overall I'm leaning towards the Falken's (P-rated) and then we'll see how they fare on the trail - if nothing else, they should be better than my stock GY adventures.