These are all shorter boats, right?
I rented 10 foot Loons by Old town for a while, then rented a 13 foot "Adventure" for a camping trip. When it came time to buy, I got the 12 foot Old Town (I forget the model) and the ex got an 11 foot Loon. There is a huge difference in just a foot or two in how they handle. The shorter boats fatigue me much faster, it is harder to keep a straight line.
If you are paddling the back bays, I'd suggest some longer boats. I use mine (12 foot) on the Wading River, Egg Harbor River, Bass River, and Mullica River and don't have any trouble turning it about or paddling long straight stretches. It gets pretty shallow and tight in the upper Mullica, especially putting in at Atsion. If I were on back bays more often I might want an even longer boat. I've paddled parts of the middle Delaware (by Bull's Island) and the "rapids" (at lower water) on the Lehigh river around Jim Thorpe without any trouble, so the boat isn't
too big either.
Everyone else on the Lehigh River trip swamped their smaller boats, and not because they were any less experienced paddlers.
You're in Manahawkin...I'd have no problem paddling to the Island from the end of Bay Ave in my boat or one longer, but would consider it torture in a 10 foot boat.
Now if you also plan to kayak the surf on the island, different story. I'd likely drown myself trying that in my boat!
Oh, all my references are sit IN boats, not sit ON boats. I think the principles are the same though.
One last thought...weight. Consider when you are shopping how you will transport the boats, and whether you can load/unload by yourself. My ex's boat is much lighter than mine because mine is compartmentalized and a foot longer. Lifting it to the roof of the Cruiser myself can be a chore at the end of a long paddle. She is not tall or strong enough to help much, either. This really wasn't a problem until I hurt my shoulder, but it is still worth considering.
My 2c...
Oh, if you want to take a few boats for test paddles before buying, Bell Haven in Green Bank let us take 10 or 12 boats out of the racks and try them out on the lake right there on the property. Their prices were fair too. Well,at least 8 years ago they were. I'd think the dealers on the island (or near it) would be more expensive as well.
Jersey Paddler has a
PaddleSport show at the end of March, too.
Edit: INSAYN beat me to many of the same points while I was "composing".
