PURCHASED!
I happend to buy the Genesis Base Camp last night. My wife and I were in a Cabela's and they happened to have one in stock. We had talked about this stove earlier in the week and she didn't flinch at the price so I picked it up.
For the last five years we've been using the Coleman "Perfectflow" Fold N Go. When I saw this Genesis online a couple weeks ago, it sounded that it was designed off of the Coleman and that Jetboil improved it. What we've liked about the Coleman was its size and that it folded in half. But what we didn't like about it was that it has only two settings being
high flame and high flame! For example cooking on the Coleman, we tended to burn things before they finished cooking. Burgers were burned on the outside and the insides were under cooked, or the bottom of a pan fried pizza was burned before the cheese melted. A typical practice the wife and I have with the Coleman was to only use one of the two burners at a time and move the cooking pan randomly from the heat to the second burner to get the high heat off of the pan throughout the cooking process.
The Coleman has no simmer!
The Coleman in action:
Right away on the box of the Genesis it notes,
“Don't settle for one stove setting.” And that it has four flame settings. I can right away feel that in the control knob it has resistance for setting the flame.
The Genesis also has a slightly smaller foot print, and if you get the base camp, it comes with the two light weight pots (the frying pan is also ceramic coated with a light weight thick plastic lid) that are wrapped around the stove, in a nice carrying bag. To be fair, the Coleman also has a nice larger bag (separately sold) that has more pockets inside and even two outside slots for the small propane bottles, but again the Genesis is overall smaller and for us, space is always in issue. Also about the pans, typically we only use one pan for most meals, and with these two pans in the same bag, we'll no longer be carrying two heavy cast-iron pans. Theses will do it for us.
Another selling point with the Genesis is that you can connect other Jetboil burners to it to all run off of propane, which I've been looking at their coffee press.
It's also nice that it uses propane, as besides the small bottles, my trailer also has a 11# propane cylinder on the front that it will hook up to.
I have yet to actually turn it on, which I'll update this later when I do (all of my propane bottles are in my trailer that is currently in storage).
Pictures…
I included a coffee mug in this picture so you can get an idea of the size of the bag it comes in. It's really a small, compact design.
Opening the bag and you see the ceramic coated frying pan with a really nice lid over it to protect it. I'll note that the lid fits both the frying pan and pot and also has holes on one side for draining.
Once the frying pan comes out, the stove is under it, inside the larger pan (I think I'll keep some paper towels between the two).
The stove will hook up to the propane, and then you can also chain a Jetboil satellite burner to it.
The construction is a notch above the Coleman. The grates are removable for cleaning, and a tighter fit/better design. As far as the propane use, I assume it will be similar to the Coleman which did not eat propane (and in fact with the Genesis having lower setting, it should lower the propane usage).
There are two black straps that keep the two sides together when packed up. Each side also has an easy to use igniter.
Inside the top of the bag has a place for the propane bottle connector.
Could I continue to be happy with the Coleman Fold N Go? Yes, if I didn't know about the Genesis, but the consent high flame that the Coleman has is its issue and has been our number one complaint. Sure the Genesis is not inexpensive, but so far the JetBoil Genesis looks like a winner and is everything that I wanted the Coleman to be.
The one/main issue that I've commonly read about the Coleman that this one will also have is that there are no wind guards. However whenever wind has a been an issue while cooking, I have just used the bag or whatever to block the wind. Plus, with this stove design, the large pot that comes with it, the pot actually sits around the grates so it does have more wind protection.
Hopefully we should now be done with buying stoves. And happy cooking in the bush... :chef: