Picking my Escape Vehicle: UJZ100, GX470, Taco or 4Runner

pdsftw

Adventurer
I posted this in the LC forum as well, but figured I would post here as I would like to get some feedback on Tacos and 4Runners. (sorry if this is some sort of violation of policy, but wanted to get some visibility as the question pertains to both platforms).



New to posting on this forum - recently posted pictures of my trailer build that will be complete in about a month: Utility Build

Here is the fairly brief backstory: I recently turned 30 and have been running my own business for about 7 years now in Texas. While I enjoy the work and want to continue to see the business grow, I also know I need to scratch an itch. I want to visit those places I read about every month in Outside, on the blogs, in this forum, etc. I realie there is an opportunity cost to embarking on something like this, but I feel that it's worth it. My plan is, that for the next few years (at least), I want to take regular 1-6 week 'sabbaticals' from work and pick an area to explore. I want to pack up all the stuff I love: my road and mountain bikes, my fly rods, my surf boards, my boats, my tent, boots, and anything else you can imagine, and head out without too much of an agenda. Move where the weather/interest takes me - be able to be flexible to extend or cut short trips depending on all the variables. I would bring along my phone and laptop to keep on some work duties as necessary (gotta keep the lights on back home, haha).

My ultimate goal would be to find a place/city/people that I really like, buy a few undeveloped acres and then procede to build or renovate a small, simple, clean house. Something I could get away to, or something that would be more permanent. While I dont have lots of overhead (not married, no kids, no mortgage), I do have a girl I love and want to share some of these experiences with her.

...so, on to the more technical of things - finding the right vehicle to kick this thing off.


So, what do I want from a vehicle?

- Be able to be a daily driver. I dont have a long commute - but I live in TX and 100+ degree days with no A/C or excessive road noise rules out a few rigs. To me, this basically means something from the past 10-15 years.
- Around town: I like to be able to put boxes/bikes/etc in my 4Runner - the back seats are rarely up unless I have to pick up extra friends, haha. The space of the 2010 4Runner has been fine and I think all the things I mentioned would work.
- Capabilities: I am not looking to crawl or so mega-serious stuff. I want to be able to get myself to some scenic places and then take out my bike or boots and get out there. Sure, I want to do some high mountain passes and I want to be about to get pretty far out there. Realistically, most new stock 4Runners, Tacos, FJs and LCs could likely handle 95% of what I am talking about. But I want something built tough and built so that I could have a good chance of getting myself out of trouble.
- Reliability: all the platforms I have mentioned are what I would consider reliable. They have their quirks from year to year, but I looking ot buy something that is fairly depreciated (ie, higher mileage) - dont mind doing regular maintenance, but I dont want to be doing heavy mods to keep it going (obviously this is often up to lady luck, but you get what I mean).
- Towing. I want to be able to tow the trailer I am building, which will serve as a base station for the adventures. I have yet to weigh it, but my estimate is that dry, it's going to weight in the neighborhood of 1500-2000LBS - I'll know more when I weight it after all the metal work is done in a few weeks. Add fluids, gear and sometimes a 400lb vintage xs650 scrambler build and you got some weight. Call it 3000lbs or so. That's not a ton of weight, but at altitude on a grade...you're going to notice it unless running a purpose build tow rig. Again, I am not planning on doing extreme terrain, but it is an off road trailer and forest roads, desert washouts and mountain passes will be encountered.
- Storage/Expo Rigging: I think all the vehicles I am looking at have enough aftermarket support and space to handle what I want. The GX would likely be the hardest to outfit, but there are overseas parts as it's on the 120 chasis and, as you likely know, called the Prado elsewhere.

Right now, I have a 2010 4Runner Trail w/KDSS, etc. It's a great tuck with a few mods and very capable on the sort of stuff I would want to do, but.....I am not sure I want to start hacking it up. It's pretty clean right now and still carries a pretty good resale value. For conversation's sake - let's assume I could get $30K for it...I could either add the $10K or so in parts i want to complete a build....or I could buy something used for about $15K-20K and then drop $10-15K into it. Effectively spending less out of pocket and on a vehicle that's already depreciated a bit more. I want to keep this car for a long time - but would plan on getting a stock commuter car should I remain in TX a few years down the road.

So, after all of that, would be great to get your opinion on what vehicle I should choose:

1.) 2nd Gen Tacoma - something like THIS rig would be awesome, haha. Nice storage, fairly good MPG, lots of aftermarket support, etc. Negatives would be fairly small cabin in comparison, smaller V6 - can anyone comment on how it would tow 3K? I know you can always drop new gears in there as the build in the link above did.

2.) GX470....man, I WISH I had been looking a few months ago, because that Bundu Gear truck is awesome. They have nice room, comfy drive, proven V8. Downsides would be the aftermarket support and the air suspension. There are bumpers and all that out there, but not as readily available as the other platforms.

3.) LC UJZ100/LX470: proven proven proven. Tons of knowledge and aftermarket support. Cons - heavy/big as hell - has the same V8 as the GX but tips the scales some 800lb more. Would make navigating small parking lots in town tricky, haha.

4.) 4th Gen 4Runner V8: I have had 3 4Runners and love them. My parents had a V8 4th gen and it has a pretty meaty engine that would tow fairly well. Decent aftermarket support. Cons: smaller cabin and out of the 4 listed...and I know this doesnt really matter, probably my least favorite aesthetically - though when fully built they can look mean.

For right now, I think that I can find and make all 4 types work in my budget (call it $40K max). Obviously the LX trades for more than a similar year Taco, but years/miles would vary to keep this build within budget.


Alright, if you are still reading...then thanks. If you have experience or want to chime in, then please reply.

Much Thanks!
 

Plannerman

Wandering Explorer
I have nearly the same Tacoma as you referenced with 32" tires and stock gears and regularly tow a 3,000 lb boat. It tows very well and imagine it would tow even better with 4.56 gears.
 

Vantage

Adventurer
I currently own a 2011 Tacoma double cab TRD on 32's.

I have also owned a 2004 V8 4runner.

I loved the Runner and regret selling it, more so this last week. I took my small trailer and camping gear up the Canadian Rockies.

The truck seemed underpowered and overwhelmed by the load. The trailer weighs 1200 pounds, and I had 200 pounds of gear.

Unless you need the box on the Tacoma I highly recommend any of the Toyota V8 vehicles.

The 4.7 is an amazing engine and tranny. Opt for a 2006+ Runner and you get more HP due to variable valve timing.

They all respond well to mods and work great offroad.
 

pdsftw

Adventurer
I currently own a 2011 Tacoma double cab TRD on 32's.

I have also owned a 2004 V8 4runner.

I loved the Runner and regret selling it, more so this last week. I took my small trailer and camping gear up the Canadian Rockies.

The truck seemed underpowered and overwhelmed by the load. The trailer weighs 1200 pounds, and I had 200 pounds of gear.

Unless you need the box on the Tacoma I highly recommend any of the Toyota V8 vehicles.

The 4.7 is an amazing engine and tranny. Opt for a 2006+ Runner and you get more HP due to variable valve timing.

They all respond well to mods and work great offroad.

Thanks for the input. I think that without re-gearing the Tacoma is likely a little small. Maybe I should be looking more towards the Tundra...but I am thinking it would be a real squeeze in my garage, haha.
 

pdsftw

Adventurer
I have nearly the same Tacoma as you referenced with 32" tires and stock gears and regularly tow a 3,000 lb boat. It tows very well and imagine it would tow even better with 4.56 gears.

See I hear that, but then I also see the post that came just after yours. Maybe it just depends on what you are used to or expecting. I am not expecting a dually-like tow....but I also dont want to be sitting doing 45 with my engine at 3K+ on a grade....
 

Clutch

<---Pass
Tundra, then you can throw a bunch at it without worrying (much) about, weight, power, or lack of space.

IMG_1337-1000.jpg

tundra1.jpg


toss on a topper, and you have a cavernous void for gear

1069414_10151719301157248_1789347902_n.jpg
 
Last edited:

surlydiesel

Adventurer
I would vote for a Tundra as well. 05-06 with low miles, 4.7 V8 and you can go extended cab or crew cab. Plenty of pep and it has the bed for the bikes, with a cap of course for safety and to keep them dry. Decent milage and "enough" aftermarket to set it up nicely.

-jorge
 

Willman

Active member
Tundras are nice for sure. Don't throw out regearing your taco. It sure helped with my Tacoma I only wish I would done the 5:29 gears.
 

Vantage

Adventurer
I just did a trip through the Rockies and was stuck in 4th as 5th up the hills towing my small trailer mentioned above (1200lbs). I do have the 6 speed standard on my truck and do not recommend it. My 4 runner towed the trailer as if it wasn't there.

And FYI

4runner - 3400-3500 pounds
GX470 - 3800
Cruiser - a little more.

The weight starts to add up.

Most 4runners have rear air as well. Sports and Limiteds all come with it standard. Many people swap it out and the runner and gx are the exact ae process. You can also trick the rear air to ride higher which will lift the truck but provide a stiffer ride with less droop. I am unsure if 100's have the air.
 

Vantage

Adventurer
I looked at a tundra when I got my taco.

The 07+ are a little big for me, the 05-06 are a perfect size if you don't need the rear seating.
 

Plannerman

Wandering Explorer
See I hear that, but then I also see the post that came just after yours. Maybe it just depends on what you are used to or expecting. I am not expecting a dually-like tow....but I also dont want to be sitting doing 45 with my engine at 3K+ on a grade....

I think you have a good point, towing "capability" is more about expectations with this group of vehicles (and probably with most Americans). If I remember correctly, the v8 4runner has a towing capacity of 7400 lbs, the Tacoma has a capacity of 6500 lbs, and the remaining options are rated for 5000 lbs.

My expectations are probably different than most. Our typical tow vehicle is a 6.7l cummins Ram with 650 ft-lbs of torque. It tows our fully loaded horse trailer like it's imaginary. Hell, it would probably tow my house without breaking a sweat, if need be. But I long since learned that towing is not the same as regular driving (largely due to hauling livestock). When towing our boat with my Tacoma, I do not expect to pull a hill at 70 mph. I'm quite happy to downshift and I'm quite happy to run at 55 mph. That being said, the Tacoma did pull the trailer easier before I lifted it and added bigger, heavier tires.
 

daveyboy

Adventurer
I suggested a newer Tundra in your other thread asking this same question.

Regarding the 05-06 Tundra--that generation in a DC is actually LONGER (barely) than the newer model (excluding DC with an 8' bed).

Also, it has been my experience that when really loaded/towing with smaller displacement engine vehicles, you get no better (or even worse) MPG than using a larger engined vehicle.
 

DanKunz

Adventurer
My GX is rated for 5000, but pretty sure that had to do with the stock towing setup. I have stronger now on my custom bumper. Plus for day to day it is awesome.

215967_10151164616258123_152152763_n.jpg
 

ol' scott

Adventurer
I'm going to throw something out here.

Keep the 4Runner. You've got a 4Runner Trail Edition with a locker from the factory? It basically does everything you want it to do except for maybe 5% that you think it might not be able to handle. If you're wanting to keep the vehicle for a long time why sell something that you already know the history of and is newer? Ask yourself: 10 years from now are you going to want a 13 year old vehicle (your 2010) or a 18, 19 year old vehicle? I know it's exciting to buy a new vehicle (I've bought and sold 7 in the last 5 years) but the vehicle you own now is by all accounts an extremely capable vehicle out of the box. Throw some sliders on there, good tires, and you're good to go, even for stuff you think you can't handle now. Scrapes and scratches will come but you'll become more and more comfortable with them. Unless you're trying to get out of a car payment (did I miss that?) just stand pat and love your vehicle. Just my suggestion of course.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
189,970
Messages
2,922,747
Members
233,207
Latest member
Goldenbora
Top