4x4junkie
Explorer
We had considered explorers but the problem is in availability in our price range. I realize that I'm asking a lot, but we're trying to keep our initial budget at around $2000. We've seen a few possibilities, but mostly they include lines like "not sure whats wrong" and "needs new transmission".
That's a bit surprising... I guess I haven't looked in awhile, but not that long ago (a few years maybe) I recall Explorers in decent shape being quite plentiful within the $1500-3000 range.
I'd still take a look at the "not sure what's wrong" and the "needs new trans" ones. You never know what you might find... Most issues (maybe except a blown auto needing a rebuild) are pretty easy fixes on these trucks (and even still, a malfunctioning trans could potentially be just a sensor or solenoid or something).
A stickshift would eliminate a lot of worries though if she's able to drive one (somewhat common in 2-door models, but relatively rare in 4-door ones).
The OHV 4.0L V6 engines are very solid motors that will go 300K+ easy if maintained.
Cherokees IME seem to be somewhat of gas hogs compared to any of the Fords, but otherwise are good, if not quite as refined, choices.