Ouch...
I started adding up the remaining costs for rebuilding the axles and brakes, to include all of the consumable parts and brake lines. It came up to almost $900- just to get it back to a stock configuration. I paused a little bit. I've spent quite a bit already.
Now I have been offered the following for about the same price:
- Dana 44 off of a '67 CJ-5, with an offset diff. It has a Detroit, 4.88 gears, a Warn full-floater conversion (30 spline axles), and disc brakes (90% off the shelf, common US parts). There is a provision for an emergency brake.
- Dana 30 out of a '80 CJ-5. It has an Ox locker, 4.88 gears, and a Warn internal hub conversion.
Here's the kicker- they are off a vehicle that burned, so they will have to be completely rebuilt. I really don't want those particular lockers, so they will likely be sold for $300 or so. The gears will be changed to 4.10s, and I'll likely install the axle off of my CJ-5 on the Rover, because it has an ARB and has been relatively recently rebuilt. I could probably get some money for my Rover axles to offset the cost of the gears and install (I don't do axles or engine internals)- eBay Rover owners would love me. I would have to buy new wheels, but they are much cheaper and more readily available than Rover wheels, which I could sell to offset the expense somewhat.
I'm going to look at them this weekend, but I'm thinking if the housings are and the Warn parts are still alive, I can rebuild the axles for less than $1000 and have 4 wheel discs, 4.10 gears, and an ARB (or two if I pull my CJ-5's rear axle). My brake system would be built entirely from domestic parts, making it much cheaper to build and maintain.
Tough call.