Automatic? I have a manual, so 5.13s would be way too high (for me) on the highway. I also have a relocated exhaust, so when I go over 3000rpm for a while, the drone becomes a bit annoying. Higher RPMs gives you more power, but also comes with higher fuel consumption and noise (depending on your exhaust setup I guess).
If I remember my RPM tables correctly, down-shifting from 6th to 5th gives you the same result as going from 4.10s to 4.88s -- something to try on the highway to get an idea of the torque / rpms / noise.
js.
No, the 3.8L/5.13:1/35" JKU has a standard transmission.
Engine RPMs at ~65mph/105kph would be roughly 2700.
The Jeep was very nice to drive and no engine noise issues, even with the top down. {As an aside, the "Hill Assist" rollback counter measure was... interesting. I'm sure it would be useful in the rocks offroad, but it would take a little to get used to.}
See this table, which assumes a 1:1 ratio. The standard in the JKU has 1:1 fifth, .84:1 OD sixth.
http://www.4lo.com/calc/geartable.htm
Higher highway RPM's may or may not lead to decreased milage. Much depends on the load, trailer or not, grades encountered, even the wind. But, if you're already turning better than ~2200rpm or so, then I have to agree that for daily driving milage will decrease.
My JKU is a five speed auto with 4.88's, with 3rd at 1:1, fourth at .75:1, fifth at .67:1. At 70mph/112kph RPM is right at 2000, but with the Hemi that is about perfect. There is no lugging or gear hunt at any mph/kph or engine rpm.
I wouldn't mind 5.13's in the 3.8L engined JKU's to help overcome the "unabundance" of power down low from that engine. And while the Hemi produces as much torque at 1250rpm as the 3.8L does max, more torque, more rpm at slow speeds = more control, etc.
4.56's and 35's are essentially equal to factory 4.10's and 32's in the Rubicon, 4.88's aren't that far off either. If you have the chance to drive a 4.88 or 5.13 geared manual it would be enlightening to everyone if you gave your impression vs. your 4.56's, especially off road.
JPK