Defeat what / whose purpose? Mine is to have ventilation / air circulation while I sleep in the parked and shut off vehicle in the summertime. It it's raining it's likely cool enough I don't need it. And it takes all of 5 seconds to remove / replace it, during a rainstorm. So why would I need to bother with a gutter / shield?...
One could likely fit the common available shields and build a fan insert that utilizes 60mm fans instead. A row of (8) would fit in the same space as my 120mm design. And at 15-25cfm each you'd get about the same total cfm as the 120mm design and have it fit up tight under a aftermarket rain / vent shield.
...
defensiveness aside, I think the Forum readers extend past the SW Desert line and assumed the post was intended for a broader audience. hypothetically, a person could fall asleep when it was not raining, and said rain event could take place while they were sleeping so soundly their slumber could go uninterrupted. and yet, they could awaken to a breakfast of soggy cornflakes
think how their entire annual vacation would be ruined, when a simple rain deflector could have prevented such a tragedy.
oh ffs, that isn't even quality hectoring. 'Soggy cornflakes.' This is 'Overlanding'. All our gourmet pan-meal fixings are supposed to be in pelican cases.
/I've got your 'defensiveness' right here