Been slacking on the updates. Geez.
Some of this is not particularly fascinating as its on every other build as well, but I'll try to provide some of my personal experiences.
First up: Icon suspension.
Nothing special there, except that I'm pretty displeased with it at the moment. The rest of this post is not a bash against ICON, they are a company trying to serve many needs of many customers, and make a fully road legal and safe product. In fact, my only complaint with them is that I wish that they had called me during my shock rebuild to verify what I wanted. At this point, I can't tell if they did a revalve or not.
Essentially, I got their stage 1 kit, so yes, not the CDC adjustables (wish I had), and got the rear springs they recommend (OME 890's). There was a warranty issue at the beginning: the passenger front shock was leaking oil. Not too big a deal, except that they make you pay for shipping one way. Not the worst thing in the world, but 50 bucks is 50 bucks. And 2 weeks of downtime on a DD isn't easy.
But thats not my actual source of displeasure. I got them knowing they were re-valveable, and so I could tune them as I wanted.
Reviews on many sites, and talking with people, suggested that they would be excellent right out of the box. They were a lot better than my old crap bilstiens, but not what I had hoped for. Good news though, ICON will revalve once for free, and since I had to send one shock back for warranty, I figured I'd just send all 4. So I did. I spoke on the phone with a tech before sending, and told them exactly what I wanted, and they said, no issue.
Get them back, and the leak is fixed, and has stayed fixed, but the ride is still not right. In fact, I was expecting a very noticeable difference, and didn't feel any change at all.
I found most of my problem was at the rear: As you can see, I have a tire carrier and 33's, so I figured perhaps my springs were off. However, I feel no change with stock springs and 1.5" spring spacers, or with FJ80 7 wrap fronts (what I had with the bilsteins).
The take home message for any reading with regard to suspensions is: Everyone's opinion of "good" is different. As you can tell, I want a "good ride". To me, a good ride is driving down a street or a washboard road at about 10-15 psig in your tires. You are aware of the bumps, but only peripherally. I want that same ride in my truck at 30-35 psig.
To others, such as my dad, a "good ride" is one where it rides like a "truck", read: STIFF. Corners on rails sort of thing. So, for the latter, a stiff spring and stiff shock valving will "ride really well", which means it handles well in corners, and doesn't sway around or lean. The price you pay in a conventional shock set up (no variable damping) is that you feel every bump so badly that it displaces fluid in your spinal column.
Now, this could all be an issue with my springs/shock tuning. I did use the springs they recommended, and despite asking for a softer front spring, ICON will only supply a 650 lb/in front spring. So, not ideal if you want a softer ride, but I do have a skid plate, ARB front bumper, and winch, so I do need a heavier than stock rate.
Scratch that, I do have one further complaint about ICON, which is that they recommend that you not turn the collars on the fronts down past 1" of thread showing. I have a little over 2, and that nets me just barely 2" of lift. One of my options is to back the collars off on the fronts, and run 1.5" spacers up front.
I'm working on buying shims from ICON. However, a full kit is 400 bucks and Id need two, one for the 2.5 fronts, and 1 for the 2.5 rears. The kit has many sizes and thicknesses, but is overkill for what I want to do. I likely only need to revalve compression, but since I don't know whats in there, or what will work, I'm torn between pulling them apart, waiting on shims to come, then trying new shims, refilling and re-charging, and then waiting for another size down the way. It would be nice to have the selection, but after getting it dialed in, I will have a very expensive box of shims sitting around collecting dust, which isn't ideal.
I'll post back up with my results once I've figured out how to do it.