Patagonia MT 40k mile torture test and review.
Milestar Patagonia MT 37x12.5 R17
I had these tires for nearly two years and approximately 38,000 miles. Miles were broken down to approximately 1,000 miles of 10-15psi technical trails/crawling. 9,000 miles of 15-20psi fast dirt roads/washboard. 2,000 miles of 15-20psi 75mph highway driving. 18,000 miles 50psi highway driving. All these numbers are approximate, I do not have the time or patience to retrace all my adventures and get the exact miles for all my trips.
Based on the numbers above, I beat the crap out of these tires and they held up remarkably. This is the only tire I will ever put on this off-road adventure specific vehicle for the rest of it's life. It's an LT tire, load D, M+S rated. I chose this tire primarily because of the low weight 71-74 lbs, most being closer to 72 lbs. This is the lightest weight MT tire available in 37x12.5 size. Only BFGoodrich AT KO2 and Cooper discovered AT were lighter at 60 and 70 lbs. but they were AT not MT. Secondly the price was unbeatable. I paid $204 per tire shipped for the first set I bought.
Balancing: they took 4-6oz each, not too bad for a tire this size. One tire took 12oz, I asked the tech to strip the weights and start again, took 8oz the second time around, still not too bad.
Highway driving: when inflated to 45-50psi the tire is silent, it's quieter at 65mph than Toyo Open Country MTs standing still or BFGoodrich KO2s at 25mph. Center block strip rolls effortlessly and steering is very quick and responsive while getting the same miles per gallon as I was with the Nitto Dura Grappler Highway Terrain tires these replaced. Highway driving at 15-20psi is doable on the highway at 70-75mph but the pitch and yaw of a 6,000lb truck gets to be a little nerve wrecking. No issues with the excessive sidewall flexing even at low pressures on the highway. Steering is a different story, I broke a power steering pump trying to man handle these tires on the pavement with low pressure and not moving. Apparently the surface area increases so dramatically that unless the truck is moving turning the tires creates too much friction.
Dirt road driving: this is what just about everyone considers off-road driving. Dirt roads or washboard. At 50psi the ride is paint can shaker unbearable, however when dropped to 20psi for regular dirt or 15psi for extensive washboard 10" of sidewall provide a magic carpet of a comfortable ride. My toddlers always fell asleep within minutes of getting of the pavement, guess they approved of the gentle rocking of the truck off road even at speeds of upto 65mph. Back to 20psi off road driving. When deflated the footprint increased dramatically, ride was smooth and stable. Cornering was precise and deliberate. Huge blocks cleared sand, gravel, mud and snow very effectively. We covered several thousand miles in Death Valley over two years, with many 250-300 off-road mile days. Not too many people can leave Vegas, run up to Eureka sand dunes via Death Valley Rd, cruise up Steele Pass, then down Saline Valley Rd, up Lippincott Pass, and out via Ubehebe RD or Hunter Mountain Rd and back to Vegas via Echo Canyon Rd all in one day with a couple toddlers.
Sand: I spent many days playing around in the sand dunes. Had to run 10-15psi for best grip and ride. Made it to the top of 300-400ft tall competition hill in Amargosa, not too shabby considering I watched many dirt bikes fail lap after lap. Toyo Open Country MTs were better in the sand than Patagonia MTs most likely due to the 1" wider tread. I only got stuck once due to driver error but overall these tires took everywhere I pointed them in the sand. Could be better but I am still happy.
Snow: Snow covered trails upto 1ft deep was not an issue. Not quite as grippy as BFGoodrich KO2s but never got stuck and went through and up everything I pointed the truck at. Similar to sand, it does well but not as good as others.
Mud: I just moved to New England at the tail end of Mud Season. Had a chance to run a couple trails and explore my own back yard over the last two months. Never had to use 4wd on trails even in deep and rutted mud trails, had to use 4wd in my back yard, never got stuck, never had issues. Huge blocks clear mud extremely well and the tires are very happy even in the deepest and muddiest trails I went on.
Durability: 8ply D rated. I was skeptical about the sidewall strength however I was proved wrong. Two months after mounting them I went on an advanced trail that I had absolutely no business being on. Even RZRs and dirt bikes deemed it impassable. It was a fun adventure of sharp pointy rocks which turned into 2-3ft sharp pointy boulders. I lost a running board and shredded the sidewalls of all the tires really bad. I drove with the gouge int he picture above for over a year before another sharp pointy lava rock in a volcano finally finished off my sidewall. This plug held good at around 8.5psi for 26 miles until we got off the trail. Much more durable than D or E rater BFGoodrich KO2 or Nitto Dura Grapplers.
Overall: Extremely happy. Overall a great tire. Excellent on highway, dirt roads and mud. Could be better in in sand and snow. Tread wear is acceptable, around 40,000 miles of unnecessarily hard abuse. Tread blocks remained soft and grippy all the way to the end. All things considered this is the best tire I could possibly have for a budget minded overland/adventure vehicle.
Only caveat with this tire is that you really should have a way to deflate and re-iflate these tires for the appropriate surfaces. Running at 15-20psi on the highway is just as retarded as running 45-50psi on washboard. I'm sure I lost a couple thousand miles of tire life from running underinflated on the highway. With the money you save on a set of these you will have enough left over for an ARB twin compressor, which is a win-win in my book!
Stay tuned for more shenanigans!