I am following this thread with great interest. My big issues with LR is guality/main. As I keep vehicles for very long time.
In 2013 I was at dealer and agreed to buy RR Sport and was asked to wait for business manager to finish up so I could get my paperwork done. While waiting I sat in my 2004 jeep GC with almost 200k miles and started to think about the Sports maint. issues and since we already had a 2012 528i, I really asked if I wanted two expensive to maintain vehicles at same time.
To get to the chase, I canceled sale, called up Jeep dealer and asked if they had GC Overland in stock, I literally stopped by and picked it up on way home. We gave 2004 GC to son who is still using it.
My 2014 Jeep GC (bought in Sept. 2013) now has 174k miles and going strong, with factory lifetime warranty it should last another 5+ years.
So my long winded question is will the defender come with longer than 3 yr warranty, and do you realistically expect these to be relatively easy to maintain, as opposed to reputation of older models?
I'll say this about the mechanicals. I spent 2 years researching a replacement for my 2010 Touareg TDI expecting a some point there would be a buyback due to Dieselgate, and there was. In that time I spent a lot of time in Grand Cherokees, I spent a lot of time in Ford trucks including the Raptor, and I spent a lot of time in the Range Rover Sport, and in the 4Runner and Taco.
I spent a lot of time on enthusiast forums for all of these, very carefully researching what kind and and how often certain serious problems came up. As mentioned, infotainment sucks all around - I believe people just want their infotainment to work like their smartphones do, which is largely reliably.
Of all of these, I found Ford trucks, RRS (post 2014 NAS spec), and 4Runners seemed to be the best by far - roughly in order. JGCs were atrocious in terms of "big" problems that would leave you stranded - diff failures due to debris left in at the factory, oil leaks, trans failures - and that was aside from build quality issues like misaligned tailgates (in some cases signaling frame issues) and rippling dash surfaces.
A Raptor doesn't fit in my garage, and you can't really enjoy them unless you live in the desert Southwest, but that was my #2. 4Runners are just so outdated for what you get - TRD Pros going for over $45K lacking any sort of real improvement over the previous 5 years at the time.
The RRS surpassed Acura, Audi, and other stalwarts in 3-year dependability - the fact that the RRS beat a Honda product is telling.
When I heard the D5 would share platform and mechanicals with the RRS but have better off road geometry, I couldn't pass it up, especially after I got $30,000 from Volkswagen for my 7-year old 100K mile plus Touareg. A test drive in one of the press cars on tour at my dealership sealed the deal.
I took delivery in August 2017 in time to take it deep into the Wyoming backcountry for the total eclipse basically fresh off the lot. Not a soul in sight, about a half mile from the nearest road. It's been all smiles since then, with 30,000 miles on the clock. Furthermore, the Td6 engine is a joint project between Ford and Pugeot - and it now appears in the F150 diesel with some mods for heavy-duty towing. Ford wouldn't select that engine unless it could go the distance.
I don't regret my choice at all. Tata put the money where JLR needed it - into development and testing. I have no reason to expect the Defender won't be just as good.