I would call it nearly a wash so far with the GX in terms of regular and preventative maintenance. Yes, Toyota has legendary quality, but you are still buying complex, luxury vehicle and expect to pay as such. I had a harder initial pill to swallow on the LR3 getting it caught up on maintenance vs. my GX which I bought CPO.
LR3 eats LCAs, GX electronic shocks go.
GX needed a caliper for a frozen piston, my LR3 needed a wheel bearing.
GX needs timing belts, LR3 has some weak points in the cooling system.
I've taken it up black diamond trails in the Browns Camp/Rogers Camp area and it didn't miss a beat even in wet and slippery conditions.
I like the direct comparison; I believe they are apples to apples in many aspects and apples to oranges in others.
I went with the RRS CA on my LR3 and although a stiffer ride (negligible IMO) the longevity is much better as there is less elastomeric flex off-road so more life.
I did a rear wheel bearing shortly after I bought Victory so ended up doing both with Timken at the time. When I rebuilt the front between 75-100k I did both front Timken Hubs to reset the life and have been happy ever since.
LR3 def has some weakness in cooling and something owners really need to be aware of with aluminum set ups; the old Toyota cast bottom ends were bulletproof IMO but the aluminum era on any engine needs caution. I've been through few water pumps and did all the cooling hoses between 75-100k and plan to work in a few more resets in the near future as now she's at 135k and running strong. On that note, I keep a spare water pump/gasket and alternator stuffed in the truck and can do both in about 45 min (each) in a trail environment (ask me how I know the times
)
Curious to know your thoughts on the GX suspension but not to hijack the thread; just know this thread has always been a good source of information on well used RR and
@howirolla adventures for those looking to actually wheel their vehicles extensively and what it takes to maintain.