Can the iPhone 4s replace a regular camera?

My iPhone 4 replaced my Canon point and shoot. Overall the canon took better pictures but with apps like Camera+ and 8mm I can edit and upload my pictures or videos really easily. The phone is just more convenient.
 
I used my Droid II on a recent 3 day trip and was very happy with the quality of the pics and since I already carry it anyway it makes sense to use it.
Great link Chip, thanks
 
If I was to buy an IPhone 4s am I committed to a 2 years contract with a phone service provider? On Ebay I can purchase an iPhone 4s for $800 and what would owning an Iphone without service accomplish? One service provider allows, at their cheapest plan, 20 photo downloads a month to whatever. I agree the phone does take remarkable photos and video but at what cost. I am not trying to throw water on the fire I am just perplexed why I need to tie myself to a contract to take photos.
 
I have a 4s. I'm no professional photographer. So this is just my opinion, but the 4s like any other phone camera does not even come close to competing with the quality of even a simple PnS. Maybe I've purchased good PnS cameras, dunno. It's good for what it does here and there, but I find it severely lacking in low-light environments. Additionally, the buttons are way too small to take good quick action photos with gloves when skiing or cold.

I'm nowhere close to professional-quality on the photography side, so just my lay observation.
 
I can use that or of course the capacitive screen (sans glove), but either does not work well for me. I take a lot (comparatively I guess) of videos skiing with the kids and especially with an otterbox container those buttons are very hard to feel and manipulate. Despite the reviews and likely because we're often in high-light out there on the snow, I found our Nikon coolpix to be superior for what we were doing. I'm sure that doesn't compete well with a "real" camera, but in comparison between those two, I prefer the coolpix hands-down.

The 4s video "seems" jumpy. I think, however, this is due to the way the video codec is being encoded. Though both (I'm pretty sure) are h.264, I'm wondering if the 4s tries to do a little better/more compressed encoding than the Nikon and consumes more CPU, but again just from a consumer-eye, the videos from the pns just "seem" smoother in high-movement with less artifacts when I'm doing basic cutting.
 
Last edited:
that was a horrible comparison. they compare iphone to a DSLR and claim the iphone is sharper. Really? do they understand the concept of DOF? focusing?

iphone vs 5D2? in broad day light with small aperture? Open up the lens on the 5D and see what the real difference would be. 16GB iphone.. less than that for video.. you fill up the memory and then what?

I can drive a Ferrari at 20mph and claim it is only as fast as a Chevy Malibu

Dont get me wrong.. in limited situations, a cell phone, p&s can offer equivalent, or "good enough" performance relative to a DSLR in the same scenario. This article is misleading because it doesn't touch on all the other scenarios where a dSLR, P&S is vastly superior than iphone
 
Last edited:
ywen said:
that was a horrible comparison. they compare iphone to a DSLR and claim the iphone is sharper. Really? do they understand the concept of DOF? focusing?

iphone vs 5D2? in broad day light with small aperture? Open up the lens on the 5D and see what the real difference would be. 16GB iphone.. less than that for video.. you fill up the memory and then what?

I can drive a Ferrari at 20mph and claim it is only as fast as a Chevy Malibu

Dont get me wrong.. in limited situations, a cell phone, p&s can offer equivalent, or "good enough" performance relative to a DSLR in the same scenario. This article is misleading because it doesn't touch on all the other scenarios where a dSLR, P&S is vastly superior than iphone
Click to expand...


Agreed 110%. Armchair web comparison. I love my iPhone 4s and have done some Pretty Sweet Work with it; but it's not even on par with my 40D. I've toyed with the idea of the interface for the DSLR lenses just to tool around, but have only gone so far as to grab the OWLE housing for it for video + wide angle stuff.

And the P&S cameras available now at the same price point as the iPhone 4s ($400+) are absolutely bad to the bone.

So, the answer: a qualified "NO".
 
editor: we need a fresh article on the iphone 4s.. to drive traffic to the site. I'm too lazy to think of new things to write about, but since Apple raved about the camera, Chris can you do an article about the camera and angle the story about how superior it is.
Chris: uhhh I'm not really qualified to do an image comparison... but I'll give it a whirl..
editor: good, let's doooo it!
 
:) Decent article!

I guess my only opinion is in regards to the old mantra "F8 and be there". With my Droid (or Iphone for that matter) the 'be there" part is easily handled. The "F8" part might a bit more difficult but for general photography the cell phone does just fine.
Overall I'm not a big fan of multi use electronics. I feel the quality starts to lack if they try to do to many things at once. I'm fine with a cell phone making calls and I'll leave my F5 and ancient D80 to the picture making.
Who am I kidding.... I just took a picture with the Droid no less than an hour ago. :)
 
pskhaat said:
The 4s video "seems" jumpy. I think, however, this is due to the way the video codec is being encoded. Though both (I'm pretty sure) are h.264, I'm wondering if the 4s tries to do a little better/more compressed encoding than the Nikon and consumes more CPU, but again just from a consumer-eye, the videos from the pns just "seem" smoother in high-movement with less artifacts when I'm doing basic cutting.
Click to expand...

I haven't actually used a 4s yet, but I thought this iPhone 4 video was interesting. The effect of frame rate and frequency is dramatically demonstrated:


http://youtu.be/TKF6nFzpHBU
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

northwesternexposure
2022 FORD F550 GXV TURTLE XXL EXPEDITION VEHICLE, LIKE NEW, 3K MILES, OREGON
2
Replies
18
Views
7K
Pacific Northwest yetti
Pacific Northwest yetti
lchrum
One of a kind Truck Cabin.
Replies
0
Views
1K
lchrum
lchrum
N
Live the Earthroamer lifestyle in this 2010 Earthroamer XV-LT
Replies
7
Views
6K
DirtWhiskey
DirtWhiskey
H
Accessory lenses for iPhone
Replies
0
Views
941
haven
H
jerdog53
2013 Mercedes Sprinter Adventure Van Denver Co.
Replies
1
Views
3K
jerdog53
jerdog53

Forum statistics

Threads
190,882
Messages
2,932,868
Members
234,698
Latest member
OchoSolo

Members online

Total: 1,621 (members: 8, guests: 1,613)
Top