I have had mine for a while now.... I loaded it with 4 bundles of wood, wet gear after doing a canyon, climbing gear and obviously trash.... and its been top notch....
I too have a friend that fill his trasharoo with fire wood but he lay his on the bed of a pick up truck...on our way to DV....by the time we got there he had a hole on his trasharoo...
Like everything else you need to practice some common sense....
I think its well design.. however, it would be nice to see one made out of vinyl material but im sure the price would be a lot more....
Great product I think...given that it was design to haul trash and I used it to haul many other things....