MarcusBrody
Active member
I hope that the Grenadier comes together in terms of being the best version of the tried and true. It seems like it has the potential to, but until we see exactly how well those systems work together I won't be totally unconcerned given it's the first vehicle from the manufacturer. It's not like the old Defender was perfectly reliable. It was just fixable.Ha! Yeah my "Overland" accounts (Defender2.net, here, and OverlandBound) all use the same screen name. There's no "GrenadierFans.net" yet that I've found so I sort of sussed out where the best info was, and Defender2.net has some great stuff. For my needs I was comparing the new Defender to the Gren -- they both achieve a very similar outcome (1 ton payload wagon 4x4), but they do it in very different ways -- Defender relies on the latest and greatest, where as the Gren relies on the best version of the tried-and-true. I know which one I can fix the easiest so that has greatly informed my choice. After a year+ of evaluating the Defender, I'd love one as a Daily Driver, but it's firmly in second place compared to the Grenadier for me.
It sounds like you are using it in remote areas professionally and that's a different use case than mine. Whatever I end up with with be very much a life style vehicle, so I don't NEED it to do anything specifically. I live outside of Las Vegas though, so there are basically endless places to explore off road/on rough dirt roads. Both something like the Grenadier/Defender/Rivian would be fun for that. On day exploration/local camping trips, I never come close to touching the range limit of electric vehicles (though I'm not sure exactly how much different driving conditions would expect things). I would definitely daily drive the Rivian, as it would be our most efficient vehicle (though now that it's less hot, I bike to work a lot of the time). I don't think the Grenadier would be. We also take longer trips that might be a couple weeks and a couple thousand miles, parts of which are through remote areas. I wouldn't take the Rivian on those right now. But I'm not sure I'd take the Grenadier either. It would really depend on how much capability I thought I'd need vs. how much efficiency I was willing to give up as right now we do them in a Transit Connect of all things, which actually has good payload and is fine just uncomfortable driving on beat up dirt roads, if no kind of an off roader. On our big trip this summer, there were probably three times when I made the route decision I did because of our van's limited capabilities. One time I just would have explored a bit farther down a road. Another I would have chosen a different camp site (but really by only 200 yards), and the third I chose a route that honestly I'm not sure was less rugged than the one I avoided, it just wasn't marketed as something you should have an SUV for. At the end of that one, we came to a snowed in pass that nothing was getting across and would have had to turn around in whatever vehicle.
Part of why I like the Grenadier is that I just like mechanical things. I don't even think they're better necessarily, I just like them. I'm a data science professor. I am very happy doing many things with computers, but somehow I just love simple, more analog vehicles. I drove a TJ Wrangler growing up. I sold a more modern car to keep a 90s BMW when we moved just because I liked it more. The Grenadier has a strong pull for me in that direction.