Oh boy did this thread get going....
I have to share a story and some thoughts. This year, on my yearly Moab pre-easter jeep spring trip there was so much snow in Durango I couldn't get my trailer out to take my ol' Willys to Moab. I decided to rent a new JK wrangler in Moab for the 3 day trip since all my friends where bringing there locked, lifted, very built jeeps....
The silver jeep on the right has a Nth long arm, 10" stroke 2.5" shocks, ,bumps, alloy Rubicon axles, 5.13s, 5.3 GM v8, 4l65e trans, and 35" krawlers on rockmonsters along with winch, bumpers, etc. The green jeep on the right is a real sleeper. 5.3 gm v8, nv4500, 231 crawler box, flipped D300, arb lockers at both ends, flat belly, bumpers, winch, 35" KM2s with staun beadlocks, etc. Then there is my little rental jeep in the middle. It's basically a STOCK rubicon JK two door automatic with some goodyear kevlar tires that where about 50% tread.
We ended up doing Metal Masher and Hells Revenge. Both of these trails are nice because the main trail is medium hard with optional HARD obstacles. The point is, I ran both trails right next to some VERY well built jeeps. EVERYONE, including myself, was constantly impressed with the little red rental. It did everything I asked it to without any issue, It was driven like it was my own vehicle, not beat on like a rental! It was actually an amazing little jeep. I never thought I would like the JK platform that much. While it is far from perfect its a great little jeep. The soul of the jeep is very intact!
I think people are taking it for granted that you can go order a jeep off the lot with a locking front and rear differentials, a 4:1 transfer case, heavier axles, etc. This alone is amazing.
I would love to see jeep offer the diesel engine. I think people are mis-remembering the sales of the diesel engine in the Liberty. They sold MANY more units than they originally planned! They would have continued to sell if they where offered. The sales of the diesel in the grand Cherokee haven't been stellar, but I believe the cost difference is MUCH more in the grand vs the liberty.
I think at least some people at Chrysler know what we want. Did you see the concept vehicles at EJS this year. The J7 and the Nukizer where both great ideas of what we want. Will they see production...most likely not. Could you make your own J7, sure! Take a Rubicon and strip out all the carpet, throw a little lift and some tires on it, add some simple bumpers.....
Jeep vehicles have the LARGEST aftermarket support of any vehicle. Build them how ever you want, don't let the dealership stop you from that!
Things I think that need addressing from jeep....
-More engine choices from the factory. I would like to see the diesel, and I know lots of people would like to see the Hemi. The diesel development is done, its basically just california emissions and a few other states that is ruining it for the rest of us. The hemi can be done, AEV has a kit if you really want one. They even offer a manual or automatic option along with VVT now. I hear the VVT hemi with a manual 6-speed is a GREAT package. Personally I would love to see the 2.8 diesel with the 545 automatic. Does anyone even buy a 4cyl jeep anymore? Take that off the plate and give us the Hemi and the diesel!
-Long wheelbase 3-door like the J8. I really dig the J8 platform and I think it would sell really well world wide if offered, but I think we are going to be stuck with the AEV option on that one. Even if the J8 3-door body was offered on a regular coil suspension frame it would do well. The additional storage space and LARGE flat rear floor would be great! Add an option for a half cab like the old scrambler and you would make a TON of people happy. That vehicle would be a great two-person mid sized truck with the flexibility to change it back to a SUV with just a top change.
Personally. I will continue to lust after a J8 3-door diesel. For me, I think that is the best starting point.