straypoet
Active member
I think the decision between carbon and FG for walls depends on things like how large the panels are, how insulated you want them to be, how stiff (or flexible!) they need to be, and how much you care about impact protection. Since carbon is much stiffer, it makes more sense on thin panels. On thicker panels the FG is stiff enough, and is better for impact. You could add kevlar to the carbon for better impact, but $$$ and it's a bear to work with. I don't know if you have a specific need for high insulation, but when you get a pretty modest amount of insulation the need for ventilation tends be the biggest heat loss. Plus we are in little boxes, and thick insulation takes away from interior space. Tradeoffs...
I've attached a spreadsheet with some cost and weight numbers for different panel options. In the first two examples with PVC foam, the one with FG skins would be quite a bit more robust in my "wack it with a hammer" testing, and yet it's only .12 lb/ft^2 heavier. Stiffness is carbon's forte...
Thank you for the informational post, and the screenshot of your decision making spreadsheet. This will definitely play a part in my decision making process.
The dash is going to be carbon for looks and 'coolness factor', but the actual camper has two goals: strong, and light weight. I don't care if it is carbon or FG, and I don't care so much about which is cheaper, I just want the most strength for the least weight. So I will be taking your suggestions into account, and I do appreciate the voice of experience.
As I build the dash and the rest of the interior, I think I will also gain some experience that will help in the decision.