"Hello every one
I have been looking at purchasing a pop up camper.Until now, My choice has been between FWC and Phoenix Campers. I have read a lot of interesting information on many forums ..
I found the thread of Mytacco and also others on this and other forums....I met owners of these two manufacturers, have had many emails exchange and phone calls.Everyone has their own opinion, which should be based on serious and thorough investigation/research on all companies.I'm still going through information distilled in the Forums.You can find everything from the best and the worst of all companies.But I must build my own personal opinion,away from friendship or business that may exist on the Forums ..
Finally, This is my opinion based on what I have researched and my approach.
Objectively, perfection does not exist.
All brands have all known issues:I have read on this Forum, that the only occasional issues of FWC's some folks have had is some frame weld cracks around the door/windows.I don't know if they were a bad weld from the factory or others issues ....Roof leaks are also reported on All of the pop up campers FWC, ATC, Phoenix, Nothstar, Outfitter, Halmark, Palamino etc. (and even non popup campers)
Like me, you see that the perfection does't exist.For a over a year, I have met happy and unhappy FWC owners.
After and over that same time period ,I have meet and had exchanges with several owners of Phoenix Camper.
What I learned from the Phoenix owners is that they are impressed and happy with the campers light weight, durability and custom aspects.
I have chosen Phoenix over the other manufacturers as I have found the owners of Phoenix Campers much easier to work with, and they build everything custom to suit the customers needs. More, I was not willing to accept the standard antique aluminum siding of the FWC . or pay the extra for the "Smooth Fiberglass Exterior Siding". What I like most is that my camper design should evolve to my taste,
Another reason I went with the custom Phoenix pop-up over the ATC or FWC because I could get extra insulation, higher output furnace and other custom features that I wanted for winter camping. For the pop-up section Phoenix can offer a 4 layer liner upon asking for it (2 layers of thinsulate knock off sandwiched between 2 layers of fabric, while ATC/FWC offered 3 layer pack that has to be put up and taken down as needed and then stored somewhere.
Phoenix also comes with a slightly higher cab over and as a result there is nice under the bed storage or I can choose to get it with lower profile like ATC/FWC.
Phoenix Camper's are all custom, no production line .
While I understand the injury felt by Mytacco,I do not agree with the method used by him by including private mails between him and the manufacturer.
It looks to me that the company (Phoenix) did more than any other company has done or would have done.
Currently, the only remaining problem is its quality of painting.
But, the responsibiliy of the manufacturer can't be questioned.
I am going to paint my future camper.The paint on the camper will be different from that of my pickup. I know it's difficult and almost impossible to get the same paint to match, especially with pearlescent paints.
On my old land 130, I had to repaint the one side that needed repainting (right side) 3 times.The result is not perfect. I did not trial the dealer over the internet.
This is not how I do my business, but directly between myself and the dealer, where we came to an amicably deal.
This negative thread does not change my choice to go with Phoenix, If anything knowing how they care about their customers and have shown great customer service shows what a good company they are to work with.
Through my writing, I just want to show that everyone must do their own "good critical thinking" and do his/her own research and go with what feels right to them. Keep an open mind and remember some people will never be please..I don't want to develop any controversy or off topic conversation .
I am not active in the forums, for this reason.
I am a man loving communication and direct contact with the humans and just putting my 2 cents out there .
I hope that all who read my opinion understand my approach and choose to do their own research beyond what they read on these forms.
best regards
John