Update: Painted and trimmed!
So the mods continue - I spray painted the body-colored parts that were below the headlights flat black so they'd blend in, and then I used a pair of snips to trim the fender liner. I think the result is a much "cleaner" look:
I still have a bit of work to do, I want to lengthen the turn signal wires so I can hide them under the bumper.
Don't know if you can tell but the license plate actually mounts on the skid plate below the winch mount, so it's out of sight but technically "legal" since it's on the bumper and visible from the front.