I made another "harsh" discovery on my D13.
The suspension jounce bumpers, the bumpers located in the middle of the coil springs, are
totally non-functional. The jounce bumper's job is to prevent an abrupt and harsh bottoming out of the suspension under full compression. As delivered from OBI, the jounce bumpers on my D13 do
nothing to soften or limit the suspension compressions and/or protect the shock absorbers.
What do I mean? I mean that when the shocks are fully compressed, the jounce bumpers have not started to engage and absorb energy. Under full compression, there is nothing to prevent the shock absorbers from harshly bottoming out. This is a recipe for broken shock absorbers.
The jounce bumper is located inside of the coil spring on the trailing arm.
To confirm this was really an issue, I removed the coil spring and reinstalled a shock absorber. I then fully compressed the suspension until the shock was bottomed-out. As you can see, the jounce bumper never makes contact.
Shock fully compressed.
Notice the air-gap between above the jounce bumper when the shock is fully compressed. The jounce bumper is doing nothing.
A jounce bumper differs from a traditional bump stop. In addition to protecting and limiting suspension travel, a jounce bumper adds a progressive component to the spring rate of the suspension. A bump stop is usually a hard rubber block that limits suspension travel. A jounce bumper is a rubber spring that also functions as a progressive spring. The more the jounce bumper is compressed, the higher the effective spring rate becomes. In my opinion, the lack of an effective jounce bumper is contributing to the excessive sway that many Dweller owners have experienced.
I brought this to OBI’s attention in late May of last year. Their response was, “
I’ll bring this to the engineer's attention, appreciate your input!” I never heard anything more from them.
My Gen-1 Modification
In the absence of any feedback or support from OBI, I worked up a simple modification to try to address this shortcoming. I took some steel stock I had kicking around and built some spacers to lift the jounce bumpers so they will engage before the suspension bottoms out. I decided to try raising the bumpers 1-1/2 inches.
With this spacing, the jounce bumpers engage when the shock absorbers have about 1-1/2 inches of travel.
With the 1-1/2 inch spacer installed, this is what the bumper looks like when the shock is fully compressed.
I was considering increasing the spacing, but I didn’t for a couple of reasons. First, I didn’t want to “overcompensate” and second I didn’t have enough material to build more spacers. I completed this modification in late May and I used it this way all summer.
My Gen-1 Results
I pulled the Dweller about five thousand miles this summer. About 500 miles of that was on unpaved secondary roads and about 150 miles of that was on tertiary or worse roads with huge potholes and large “water bars” and “rolling dips”. I gave it a pretty good workout. Nothing broke.
To measure my suspension compression, I installed a couple of “tattletales” on the shock absorbers to measure maximum compression. It is the same idea as the external o-ring on a mountain bike shock that is used for the same purpose.
Tattletale fashioned from zip-ties and a cut up tin can.
I measured compression from the center of the lower shock mount to the top of the tattletale.
The maximum suspension compressions i measured were about 4-3/8 inch (driver side) and about 4 inches (passenger side). With the Monroe shocks, I measured full compression at 3-15/16 inches from the center of the lower shock mount. I’m pretty sure that I bottomed out the shock on the passenger side.
My Gen-2 Modification
I’m increasing the spacing to 2 inches. Instead of steel spacers, I'm going with the reliable old hockey puck. Two regulation pucks provides an even 2 inches of spacing. They look better too.
Here is what it looks like now with the pucks installed and the shock fully compressed.
I’m cautiously optimistic that this will be a lasting solution for the way I use the trailer. I'm going to continue to monitor suspension travel with the tattletales and will report any additional feedback.
Here is my material list if anyone wants to replicate this:
- 4 ea - Hockey Pucks with 25/64 inch hole drilled in the center
- 2 ea - 3/8 x 3-inch bolts
- 4 ea - Washers
- 2 ea - 3/8 Nylock nuts
Thoughts or comments?