VanIsle_Greg
I think I need a bigger truck!
If you're worried about weak sidewalls, best not buy Duracraps. They are shredding sidewalls like they're made of papier mâché around here!
I know a few people with the exact same experience here. Brand new tires, one friend went through 3 tires all due to sidewall splits on his Toyota LC (big/heavy) and the last one they wouldn't warranty. He sold them with about 10,000 KM on them at a loss. He moved to the Cooper STT Maxx and said they are hands down one of the best tires he has used ever.
Hancook DynaPro MT, Federal Couragia M/T
I run the Hankook Dynapro MT (RT03) and they are a very good tire. Their AT's are very nice as well and will find their way on to my Jeep WK this coming summer after the lift goes in.
The single most important thing I think is to look at what you are driving on most of the time and what is working for others in the area you are heading to. For overlanding, an MT is likely as not overkill, what you probably want is...
1. Durability
2. All condition traction (good in everything not great at everything...no such tire)
3. Availability
4. Legality (do they have the mountain snow flake logo/do you need it)
Personally, I would say it is a tough choice, hence the 45 threads a month on this topic on all the boards I am on. I am wary of the BFG's for a few reasons, mostly the sidewall issues. I drive on a lot of FSR and logging roads and it is all blast rock, sharp and nasty. I hear a lot of bad stories locally of BFG failures, but still a ton of them out there, so they are either good or really cheap? I also am not a fan of the BFG AT as they chuck a TON of rocks and I tow trailers. My MT's never do. I have also heard a lot of complaints about the Duratrack's for sidewall issues and premature wear...no personal experience however?
Very tough call. Might come down to availability and price for most.