Jeeeez, I'm such a tent geek. Read almost every page of this thread last night. I've thought a lot about tents over the years and have spent many an hour around the campfire discussing pros, cons and designing the perfect tents. I've come to at least one general conclusion and one specific conclusion. Generally, a tent should have as few poles as possible. It seems to me that speed and simplicity are both heavily influenced by the number of poles. Specifically, Eureka tents offer the best value of any manufacturer. The Eureka name is never compared with the likes of North Face, Mountain Hardware and the like (I'm purposely leaving Bibbler, Tuk Nuk and other high dollar tents out of this discussion). They offer tents, that I think, are easier to set up and just as rock solid of any of the mass production Gucci name tents. They also offer great quality and amazing customer service.
Right now, I have five tents and each serves a specific purpose.
- Very old Eureka Apex XT
- Kelty Buttress 6
- Eureka Assault Outfitter 4
- Kodiak Canvas 10X10 Flexbow
- Ozark Trails EZ Up Wall Tent
My Apex XT is my go to light weight 2 man tent. Stand out features are a rain fly that goes all the way down on all sides and mesh doors that have solid fabric zipper windows. This tent does great in desert high wind areas, where sand can blow up under the rain fly and through the mesh that is used on most light weight tents.
Kelty Buttress 6 has the same stand out features as the Apex XT, but in a MUCH larger package. I use this as my light weight family tent.
The Assault 4 is my 4 season family tent. It will handle more wind than any of my other tents and a light snow load. Not light weight and it has three poles, but I couldn't find a 2 pole tent that would do what this tent does.
My Kodiak is kept in my offoad trailer. I use it much more than any of my other tents.
My Ozark Trails Wall tent is used for marketing events that I attend and does not handle any wind. But it's giant.
Pics of the tents that I didn't see previously posted in this thread:
Apex XT (looks bigger in the picture than it really is)
Assault Outfitter 4 (looks smaller in the picture than it really is)
Kelty Buttress 6 (Looks much smaller in the picture than it really is - has standing headroom)
Ozark Trails (pretty embarrassed to post this)