The Eagle shell looks to weigh about 50lbs more, and the weight would be hanging off the back of the rig. Just where I do not want to add weight on the lightweight Tacoma platform. And for some reason not having to carry a step is a nice thing, one less thing to deal with.
But I do not plan on carrying my spare on the bumper, as my 32's fit in the stock location, and I have decided against an additional fuel tank. The Aluminess bumper with storage boxes looks nice, but again it is hanging the weight off the back, just where I do not want it.
I definitely do not like having the camper extend past the rear bumper. If I bump something (or something bumps me) I want the strength of the bumper, not the lightweight camper to take the hit.
With the weight saving of the Finch I could carry my Thule box. While it would not provide more elbow room in the camper, I feel the storage space would be more usable than the 10" in the Eagle. And it might provide the feel of more space as there would be less stuff floating in the camper, and that might be most important. Of course weight up high is not ideal either, but my COG will be so much better than it is with my current set up.
One other consideration is what my next truck will be, as I would like to keep the camper through multiple trucks. If I would go to a larger truck then the Eagle would fit better, but with fuel prices on the climb a smaller truck might be in the future.
I guess I can not really go wrong, but until I can order the camper I have time to think about it.
Thanks for the info on the light.
You're right, that 10" is alot. But are you going to use your rear bumper as a tire carrier or anything else? That is the only reason I would go with the Finch. Also, Eagle needs a set of steps and the Finch you can use the bumper. Finch less weight, less weight towards the rear. Eagle more room, more weight and must carry some sort of step.
I dual purpose my truck so a bumper was out of the question. The added length and weight means nothing to me. But remember, I have air bags and you like Timbrens!
My .02
Jeff
PS, you can easily run the motion detector light with no switch.