The 285s equate to a 33" tire, so they are not "big" compared to those running 35"s and small for that gearing. I am currently running around the West in our JKU, running stock KM2 32" tires turned by 3.73s but am carrying extra fuel, water, gear, and have a MRBP Off-Camber Fab roof rack and basket. We also have a 2.5" lift, which combined with the basket and baggage, isn't helping the aerodynamics. Yesterday we suffered our worst mileage of the trip, averaging 13 MPG driving into the wind from Gallup to Flagstaff at 74 MPH.
I didn't buy this rig for the mileage and think that considering the load and configuration that my mileage was right about where it should have been.