Which is better Land Rover or Hummer?

D

Deleted member 9101

Guest
H-1 hands down. We beat the **** out of them day and night and they hold up great. They are not the smallest, most nimble, or economical transportation... but they are built rock solid and have almost unlimited options when it comes to mounting things.
 

CMorris

New member
I think I've owned a lot of the vehicles you're thinking about,'97 D90, '00 Disco, '05 LR3, '06 H3, '01 H1, '73 SIII 88, '67 SIIA 109, '60 SII 88, '64 SIIA 109. The hardest any have been worked was the Trans-Labrador in the '67 109......beat it to death and it came out fine, but definitely not something to cruise around town in with the family, so rule out the Series Rover stuff. Easiest trip was messing around on the beaches of the Outer Banks in the '00 Disco.....again, the truck performed flawlessly and is quite nice to drive "on road". H1........very cool, quite capable in wide open spaces, but as mentioned above VERY expensive to maintain (and I do all my own work......parts aren't cheap), and in the end, not very entertaining to drive....over-assisted steering, heavy truck with coils at all corners, felt like driving a boat (floats?), anyhow, wouldn't be my 1st choice. H3, very capable also, only limitation may be size.....multiple kids in the family?? Back seating will be tight. So.......my pick would be either a late model (Series II) Disco, maybe one of the G4 or Trek prepped versions if you could find one, most have some nice equipment already installed (Brownchurch racks, etc.), or an LR3 V8 SE (HSE's have 19" rims, tough to find decent off road biased tires). Both the Disco and LR3 will do well off road and are quite nice to drive in town. I have no personal experience with Toyotas, but have seen some ultra nice ones in my travels and think you may want to throw the brand into your decision mix. Plenty of people here that can educate you on the brand.
Good luck with your decision!!
 

Christophe Noel

Expedition Leader
I'm no Land Rover expert, although I've owned my DII for a few years. I'm no vehicle expedition (hate that word by the way) expert although I've driven to and from Alaska a number of times. I don't think I'd feel very comfortable driving my DII to Alaska. To be frank, I'd rather take my wife's Toyota Solara. I'm not saying Land Rovers can't be super reliable, but should one take a poop while mid-transit in BC, the Yukon or Alaska itself, few places are capable of making repairs to said LR. Just my two coins.
 
D

Deleted member 9101

Guest
I think I've owned a lot of the vehicles you're thinking about,'97 D90, '00 Disco, '05 LR3, '06 H3, '01 H1, '73 SIII 88, '67 SIIA 109, '60 SII 88, '64 SIIA 109. The hardest any have been worked was the Trans-Labrador in the '67 109......beat it to death and it came out fine, but definitely not something to cruise around town in with the family, so rule out the Series Rover stuff. Easiest trip was messing around on the beaches of the Outer Banks in the '00 Disco.....again, the truck performed flawlessly and is quite nice to drive "on road". H1........very cool, quite capable in wide open spaces, but as mentioned above VERY expensive to maintain (and I do all my own work......parts aren't cheap), and in the end, not very entertaining to drive....over-assisted steering, heavy truck with coils at all corners, felt like driving a boat (floats?), anyhow, wouldn't be my 1st choice. H3, very capable also, only limitation may be size.....multiple kids in the family?? Back seating will be tight. So.......my pick would be either a late model (Series II) Disco, maybe one of the G4 or Trek prepped versions if you could find one, most have some nice equipment already installed (Brownchurch racks, etc.), or an LR3 V8 SE (HSE's have 19" rims, tough to find decent off road biased tires). Both the Disco and LR3 will do well off road and are quite nice to drive in town. I have no personal experience with Toyotas, but have seen some ultra nice ones in my travels and think you may want to throw the brand into your decision mix. Plenty of people here that can educate you on the brand.
Good luck with your decision!!

Actually, the axles are the only expensive drive train part on a H1. The engine, tranny, and transfer are all off the shelf GM parts.
 

Antichrist

Expedition Leader
You say the choice is between an H1 and a Land Rover, and you want it for general exploring. You don't say where you want to explore, but because of it's size, the H1 is going to limit you in the exploration dept.
If you're exploring desert, not so much a problems. Mountains and forests with narrow twisty trails, more of a problem.
 

Rev

Adventurer
I can't imagine trying to take an H1 down most of the trails here in Ontario - way too tight. Even my Xterra is a bit big sometimes.
 

arm and hammer

New member
H 1 is coolest truck I know , and is chick magnet too.Imagine driving a brick down the highway against the wind , just doesn't go.Land rover on the other hand drives like a sedan ( Discovery).I have D1 and D2 and I love them.I have H 1 project truck in garage and more I look more I see it is too big.I think I will downsize it.GM come to the same conclusion , this is how H3 become.For those who are curious here is link to my project.http://h1forum.tremormuv.com/viewtopic.php?t=2117
 

Ron B

Explorer
Topics like this always bring out passionate responses because we all love what we drive! It might be kind of silly to ask which truck is better as they both have advantages and disadvantages and both are highly capable vehicles.

If you want to learn about the hummer, go here:

the hml (knowledge base and marketplace at top)
http://www.hummernetworkforums.com/viewforum.php?f=3

the lynch hummer site with year to year changes and production #'s
http://www.lynchhummer.com/Changes/h1.changes/h1changes.index.html

flash offroad tech info
http://www.flashoffroad.com/humdefault.htm

I suggest driving/riding in as many vehicles as you can get your hands on and then choose what suits you the best. Don't just limit yourself to two, there are lots of great vehicles available...and they will all be money pits :)

rb
 

Trail Monkey

Adventurer, Overland Certified OC0014
Ok my 2cents on this loaded topic..

I have owned a 2003 H1 Wagon. Used it extensively offroad.

Pro's
-excellent at high water crossings
-large wheel base and foot print allow for manuvers often undoable in most trucks unless highly modified.
-diesel had good torque for offroad
-CTIS tire inflation very convienient
-large storage area in wagon rear
-good dash area for electronic farkles
-everyone loves your truck and stares at it(except a few, who give you the finger)

Con's
-very tight cabin leg room in front, both sides
-very poor visibility from all windows
-back seat is claustrophbic for most folks its useless
-road trips are loud and uncomfortable
-generally you need an H1 mechanic to do any service
-you will need alot of service, they break mechanically and electrically regularly
-you will need to carry half shafts and pitman arms offroad as the truck weights alot...
-truck is wide and long, making trail access sometimes difficult or at least environmentally unsensitive
-you will need to spend $15K on immediate upgrades to fix known problems or you will break down even more offroad
-parts and upgrades are very pricey and less and less is available now

those who disagree with all of this are just kidding themselves...!
These are great trucks, a place in my heart for mine always, like owning a ferrari for the most part. super cool and when its working its great, but youd be way better off with a porsche or a corvette..

:sombrero:
 

Ron B

Explorer
Con's
-very tight cabin leg room in front, both sides
-very poor visibility from all windows
-back seat is claustrophbic for most folks its useless
-road trips are loud and uncomfortable
-generally you need an H1 mechanic to do any service
-you will need alot of service, they break mechanically and electrically regularly
-you will need to carry half shafts and pitman arms offroad as the truck weights alot...
-truck is wide and long, making trail access sometimes difficult or at least environmentally unsensitive
-you will need to spend $15K on immediate upgrades to fix known problems or you will break down even more offroad
-parts and upgrades are very pricey and less and less is available now

those who disagree with all of this are just kidding themselves...!
These are great trucks, a place in my heart for mine always, like owning a ferrari for the most part. super cool and when its working its great, but youd be way better off with a porsche or a corvette..

:sombrero:

I will kid myself and disagree on a few of your cons:

-cramped front seats -- the passenger side is cramped side to side without the knee cutout aftermarket option. Driver's side is fine for me (6'1)

-poor visability...yes, to the rear (especially in a wagon)

-totally agree on the backseats being a mess. They aren't uncomfortable, but you can't see anything out of them! Most pull at least one rear seat and put in a fridge and/or storage boxes (center tunnel bench seat for smaller kids).

-road trips are loud, but no more uncomfortable than any other seriously capable 4x4 (going with larger tires on a hummer actually help the ride).

-true on the h1 mechanic for the big stuff. A good one can be hard to find!

-lots of service and breaking a lot -- yes, the service intervals are more than the average truck (especially compared to the typical suv) and if you do not adhere to them your truck will seek revenge. As for breaking down mechanically -- almost always driver error or computer related (the GM engine and tranny sometimes aren't on speaking terms and go into a limp mode). Sometimes h1's that sit a lot tend to have more issues.

-carrying spare parts -- of course, but I thought everyone carried some spare stuff? You will go through idlers and pitmans a lot if you wheel medium to hard trails (most on this forum don't do that kind of wheeling). Half-shafts are easy to break if you don't know how to wheel the truck (btm) or don't have lockers.

-too wide and long -- yes on wide! An h1 is a foot wider than the JK but it's only 184.5" long. That's .5" longer than an FJ Cruiser, 1.5" longer than the 4 dr JK, the same as my Passat, and 4" shorter than the 4Runner and 10" shorter than a Land Cruiser. Maybe you are referring to the long wheelbase? It's easy to high center if you aren't careful

-spending $15k right off the bat fixing what known problems? Maybe you are referring to the first year of ownership rule of thumb that it will be the most expensive year due to the previous owner's negligence? Other than that...if it's a pre '96 truck you'll want to the upgrade to hd balljoints/idler and pitman. If it's a turbo diesel, I'd recommend the $200 pmd (injection pump mounted driver) relocation kit and a spare pmd ($400). You also might be referring to the bad batch of GM engines in the td trucks from 96 to 2000 (#8 cylinder cracks...bummer). Most were done under warranty, some unlucky bastards (like myself) got screwed!

-upgrades/accessories can be expensive, especially from the dealer -- but there are plenty available through several companies online an at decent prices. And shipping on all Parts from AM-General is free (even engines!) and the parts will be around as long as humvees are driving around in the armed forces.

the thing to remember about an h1 is that it started life as perfectly functioning humvee...hand built by AM-General, who then crammed front and rear air conditioning, leather seats, a dashboard/more gauges, a stereo, trim and sound insulation and then stuck a turbo on the engine. It's closer to a tractor than to a truck and it makes me happy when I drive it.

rb
 

citthru

New member
Topics like this always bring out passionate responses because we all love what we drive! It might be kind of silly to ask which truck is better as they both have advantages and disadvantages and both are highly capable vehicles.

If you want to learn about the hummer, go here:

the hml (knowledge base and marketplace at top)
http://www.hummernetworkforums.com/viewforum.php?f=3

the lynch hummer site with year to year changes and production #'s
http://www.lynchhummer.com/Changes/h1.changes/h1changes.index.html

flash offroad tech info
http://www.flashoffroad.com/humdefault.htm

I suggest driving/riding in as many vehicles as you can get your hands on and then choose what suits you the best. Don't just limit yourself to two, there are lots of great vehicles available...and they will all be money pits :)

rb


I'm well aware of Lynch Hummer and I will check out your other links. The reason I started the thread is because there is no substitute for first hand experience. In the end the decision will be mine, but I like to hear the likes and dislike of each.
 
D

Deleted member 9101

Guest
Ok my 2cents on this loaded topic..

I have owned a 2003 H1 Wagon. Used it extensively offroad.


Con's

-generally you need an H1 mechanic to do any service
-you will need alot of service, they break mechanically and electrically regularly
-you will need to carry half shafts and pitman arms offroad as the truck weights alot...
-truck is wide and long, making trail access sometimes difficult or at least environmentally unsensitive
-you will need to spend $15K on immediate upgrades to fix known problems or you will break down even more offroad
-parts and upgrades are very pricey and less and less is available now

those who disagree with all of this are just kidding themselves...!

I have driven them since 1996... they are reliable, easy to work on.. and they do fine in trails unless they are really narrow. What breaks is the stuff added to make it more comfortable, the basic truck is almost bullet proof.


BTW: I have been shot at in them, blown up in them, jumped them, wrecked them, and honestly despite thee flaws.... they are great trucks.
 
D

Deleted member 9101

Guest
the thing to remember about an h1 is that it started life as perfectly functioning humvee...hand built by AM-General, who then crammed front and rear air conditioning, leather seats, a dashboard/more gauges, a stereo, trim and sound insulation and then stuck a turbo on the engine. It's closer to a tractor than to a truck and it makes me happy when I drive it.

rb

Give me a refurbished 998 with just a few goodies and I would take it any where in the world with out a second thought.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
188,727
Messages
2,909,519
Members
230,892
Latest member
jesus m anderson
Top