Bags versus Boxes

Lostmanifesto

Traveler
I have always relied on durable bags to carry all my gear around with me. For those of us without storage systems and rely on portable storage, what is your opinion on bags versus boxes? By boxes I mean cases or any solid shaped carry device I think you know what I mean. Bags have always been very easy for me to load my truck and unload after my trip. I have a pair of pelican cases that seem to be harder to strap down and heavier.

This all obviously pertains to storage needs inside a vehicle where weather is not an issue. Outside I would of course go with weatherproof containers.

Thoughts?

Thanks

Jordan
 

lcsodiver

Adventurer
Well I use a combo of both. I like the security of my pelican cases. But the packability of bags which will fill odd shaped spaces better. So I have some of both. My first aid kit, truck stuff (oil/grease/lubes) all go in pelican cases. I have been thinking that a pelican for my recovery gear would be good to as I had a leak that got everything wet and had to bring it all inside to dry it all out. That would also keep the thieves from being able to do a smash and grab through a window. As it's not easy to lift a case full of recovery gear and it wouldn't fit through the windows anyway. It they open the doors that sets off the alarm!

So I guess I use both and will continue as this works well for me.
 

fishEH

Explorer
I keep my tools and recovery gear in bags. Spares and anything that might leak goes in boxes. I have two 12 gallon totes usually used by stores like WalMart and BassPro to transfer small items between stores. They're pretty tough and cheap and easily bought at Home Depot. I would have preferred one large box but I wouldn't have been able to lift the darn thing, LOL.
 

cnynrat

Expedition Leader
A bit of a mix of both for us.

I used to use bags for my tools and recovery gear. I was running out of room, and tired of always having to dig down to the bottom to find what I needed, so I took advantage of the warehouse sale at Pelican a couple months ago to pick up a couple Storm Cases (they are now owned by Pelican also). They are a little more difficult to strap down, but I like the easier access they provide.

I like packing our food in hard sided boxes, mainly because it provides more protection against getting crushed.

We pack our clothing in a soft duffel bag or two depending on the length of the trip.
 

timmer2008

Adventurer
Im in the mix catagory

I use sealline bags and pelican cases

both are water / dust proof and strap down easily
 

poriggity

Explorer
Great thread, as I am just starting to build my truck for overland expedtion travel. Right now, my recovery gear is in a bag, because it fits under the backseat that way. I am still in the planning stages, but have thought about this bag vs box route for a while now, and I am still not 100% sure on which way is better.
Scott
 

TangoBlue

American Adventurist
I'm in complete agreement with cnynrat in post 4 - I do the exact same thing. I like the flexibility it gives you for securing your gear.
 

Ruined Adventures

Brenton Cooper
A lot of money can be saved by going to Goodwill (or any thrift store) and buying soft-sided bags...you can find some really quality stuff this way, get a little creative, and throw a little savings toward your gas tank. You can also find old Nalgene/Sigg-type bottles which can be used for fluids storage. I store my fluid containers in a rubbermaid tub, which serves double duty: it contains spills inside the truck and can be used to contain disastrous fluid leaks outside the truck, avoiding an Exxon Valdez/BP crisis in the boonies.

I was amazed when I took my craftsman socket & tool set and emptied it into a small canvas mechanic's bag. Not only did the bag end up taking 1/4 the space vs. the box, I was able to throw twice as many additional tools inside! This route tends to make less noise on bumps too. Bags compress so much better and hardly impact the overall weight of your kit. You can keep it organized by "nesting" several smaller bags of gear inside of the larger luggage style bags.

Sealline bags and other dry bags are great for clothes and sleeping bags. Only downsides: they cost more and there's a possibility of condensation building inside when there's a big temp differential.

Pelicans, Stormcases, etc are nice but I find them very heavy for my payload, not to mention my wallet. It's definitely worth the sacrifice if you want to protect an investment. We use one to protect our laptop and other fragile equipment (where you wouldn't want the compress-ability of bags). As mentioned another plus is security...however, you could achieve similar results by bolting down a simple homemade box that locks to fit all your soft-sided bags...if you haven't guessed I'm cheap and don't mind sacrificing a little bling
 
Last edited:

rusty_tlc

Explorer
Believe it or not I am very fond of fruit boxes, usually apple or pear.

They are cheap, well free actually.They are easy to stack and the square sides pack better than plastic bins. I really like the design. The top can be flipped on its side to serve as shelves in camp, you can stack the bottom on the top to get it up off the ground. They have built in handles and you can double your storage by using the top. The only fault I can find with them is they wear out after a season or two (I have a few I've been using for three years) not a huge deal since they are easy to replace. Someday I'll build a few out of 5mm plywood with the stitch and glue method.

I also like bags, as another poster mentioned they are great for filling in odd spaces. My solution to the "Whatever I need is always at the bottom." problem is to use what I call the bag of bags system. I use small bags to organize the contents by category.
 

off-roader

Expedition Leader
- Military surplus store heavy canvas bags for tools and tie down straps.
- ARB bag for recovery gear.
- Hard sided boxes for misc. camp gear, cooking gear, & non refrigerated foods (canned goods, breads, non-refrigerated hardy foods, etc.

It all fits underneath a sleeping platform I built in back so it secure in the event of a roll over or more frequently from being knocked around on a rock crawling trip.

On top of the platform I strapped my fridge along with soft goods like sleeping bags, thermarest matresses, tent, etc.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
189,287
Messages
2,915,134
Members
232,078
Latest member
Babbert
Top