I have a set of ST Maxx 255/85-16's on my heavy fully armored 2012 Frontier (Shrockworks skids plates, front/rear bumpers, sliders, 8K warn winch, topper, etc.).
Tread depth new is 18.5/32”, after 15,000 miles (rotating 4 at a time) they are at 8/32”, so I've used about .02” per 1,000 miles, which leaves approximately 7,000 miles of life left on these tires if we run them to 3/32”. The edges have chunked quite a bit but we spend a lot of time in 4 low in CO, NM, AZ, and UT as well as 2 and 4 high dirt roads. AZ is exceptionally hard on tires and UT takes its toll as well. I have another set of wheels with Hankook Dynapro ATM all terrain tires mounted that I use for everyday driving, the Coopers go on mainly for our off road oriented trips, so they see predominately off road use. Considering the amount of off road these tires have seen I find the wear acceptable.
The ST Maxx tires are heavy, probably around 60lbs per tire (I weighed them with a bathroom scale mounted on stock wheels and subtracted stock wheel weight, so not super accurate) and I definitely feel the rotational weight in acceleration, braking, and mpg. But these are great off road, I feel very confident airing them down to 15-18 lbs in rocks.
I can't recommend them for packed snow/icy conditions, I feel these tires are much closer to a mud terrain than an all terrain.
Note: I have not read this thread to know if my experience is similar to others, but above has been my experience to date.