I went back to Lowes and picked out stronger door hinges as a starting point for the DIY lift-off hinges. I got Stanley 4 1/2" "Commercial" hinges, they were a little less than $7.00 each. They're made from much thicker-gauge steel than the $3.00 hinges I used the other day, and they've got 5/16" hinge pins instead of the 1/4" pins the other hinges had.
Here's how they get cut:
Two nice things about these Stanley hinges - they come in primer, so they'll be easier to paint, and, because of the way the holes are laid out, no drilling is necessary, they'll end up with two holes after cutting, so there's one less step necessary to make them.
Here's a finished hinge, and a comparison to the smaller hinge from the other day.
Because door hinges are designed to be used in doors and not to hinge two flat surfaces together, the barrel is slightly offset, which means the back of the hinge isn't flat (this was true with the hinges from the other day too). I need the back of the hinge to be flat because I plan to mount the hinges so that the barrel of the tub side hinge is below the top of the tub, like this:
Making the backs flat is easily fixed by a blow with a hammer, using the scrap side of the hinge as a punch. Here's a before and after shot, and a shot showing the process:
If you're wondering why I want the hinges mounted with the barrel below the top of the tub, it's so that when the cover is removed, the hinge half that's still on the tub doesn't stick up above the edge of the tub.