After driving a handful of transits, I've come to the conclusion that I'll be hanging on to Fred for a while longer. The only things I like about the new transits are:
1) the ecoboost engine
2) the square cargo area that stays square all the way to the top
3) the great visibility out that windsheild
After each test drive I kept finding more and more things that drove me crazy - a brake pedal that's 2" too high, plastic EVERYTHING, doors that don't shut well, poor door trim, issues with the airbox letting water in (that one I read about on the forums), no front inner fender liners protecting the washer bottle, a dash that doesn't allow me to run an aftermarket stereo, no real handle inside the rear cargo door to let me out, horrid ground clearance, the fact that the windows roll down 95% of the way, but not 100% of the way (there's still a 1/2" tab of glass sticking out when it's rolled down), the fact that the 60/40 front side window blocks the tow mirrors, the ebrake lever on the floor making it tough to climb back between the seats, the fact that you have to look at the ignition to insert your key (no plastic to guide it in), the procedure for removing the batteries, the plastic cargo bin above your head, dash controls that are point away from the driver and impossible to see... the list goes on...
None of these are deal-breakers on their own, but combined they make it a no-go for me. Maybe I've raised my expectations too high after driving a lot of hondas and toyotas. I've gotten used to a car being designed well, and $40-45k should feel as nice as a 10 year old honda. The transit wasn't designed well. It feels like a bunch of bean counters called all the shots and nobody was on the same page. Every little piece feels like a shortcut was taken. If I'm going to drop $40-45k on a new van, I don't want to have to tell myself to ignore all those things because it's "better than a promasater" or "cheaper than a sprinter."
That being said, I still think the transits are my favorite modern van, but my current van is so much better on so many fronts. I think I'll add a high top and see how that treats me. Then, if in a year or two I'm still jonesing for a transit, I can pick up a used one and save a bundle. I honestly felt like the transit felt more like a kia than a solid vehicle. I respect Ford for not taking bailout money, and for making cars for so long, but the engineers must really be against some crazy constraints, because the Transit is not user-friendly in any way, shape, or form (in my opinion). The good news is that this saves me a ton of time and energy.