I guess I should chime in! My selection is an older 4 door suzuki sidekick. It will be getting the 1.6L Turbo diesel swap very soon. I am currently getting 20 mpg with 30" tires and stock gearing and a roof basket. But the power sucks! With the diesel I am hoping for close to 30 mpg (which shouldn't be a problem) bigger tires and more power.
I have taken my sidekick places it shouldn't go. This last weekend we were wheelin in 2 feet of wet sloppy snow and other than a lack of low end power I had no problems. I did air down to 6 psi though!
You don't get them in the US but my choice for a new small SUV would be the Nissan X-trail. It has a larger 4 cylinder rather than the current trend to v6's with other brands. It has been around in other parts of the world for a few years for aftermarket is out there. OME makes a lift for it! :chowtime:
I test drove one and almost bought one but couldn't get over the fact that I would wreck it on our tight bushy trails up here. Plus it didn't have a Low range.
My next option would be a couple of year old suzuki XL7 more than enough room and sep. frame and solid rear axle.:bowdown:
This is from the 5th. I was pushing snow with the white cross member later in the day!