I have a 3rd Gen Montero Limited that I wouldnt part with for the world. Room in a mid size SUV was one of the biggest factors when we bought it. I didnt want a Tahoe or Suburban sized vehicle as I have a 2500HD crew cab with a cap and didnt need to duplicate it. We looked at FJs briefly, 4runners, LCs, Rovers(I will end with another Disco in the near future but thats just for me) Jeeps, Xterras, Pathfinders. I honestly hadnt even considered a Montero, didnt even know what they were until I saw one on a lot. For the money, quality, and capability it was a no brainer. I was concerned about it only having a V6, but that worry has long since blown away. It has more than enough power for the vehicle and anything youll need to tow with that size vehicle, small camper or our 20' boat. I pulled the boat from SC to Erie PA through the mountains with no problems whatsoever. Milage is decent, my wife averages 18, I average 16. Shes a little easier on the skinny pedal than I am. Visibility is outstanding, off road capability is as good as anything you have listed above (7 Dakar wins), on road it rides like a caddy. My Dad, the BMW junky, even commented on the quality of the fit and finish. Parts are easy to come by although we havent needed much more than maintenance items. Five adults fit comfortably, with two dogs in the back, plus third row seating when needed and seperate AC in the back. Which, splitting time between South Carolina and the Rio Grande Valley in TX, the dogs love in the summer. It has the locking diferential in the transfer case you can put in 4hi and run in AWD at highway speeds, or lock the transfer case and have reg 4hi and 4lo. Plus the traction control system is outstanding almost like having locking diffs in the axles. Not quite, but close. My wife who has been a Subaru Addict for decades has decided that if they do bring back the Montero in 2014/15 like the rumor says, she wants one of those instead of a new Outback. Maybe you shouldnt buy one. Ill probably end up buying another one and they are getting harder to find.