New Defender Rage/Hate Thread

Pilat

Tossing ewoks on Titan
So sorry, don't insult yourself by claiming I don't know what a global vehicle is. Everyone knows that around the world the most widely used 4wd is a Toyota.

Sheesh! "global" does not mean "most widely used".
So, take it as an insult if you wish. But this has been explained to you ad nauseam. Hell, I even made it very very simply by giving the engine example. And you STILL don't understand it.
 
Last edited:

Pilat

Tossing ewoks on Titan
Jaguar Land Rover has markets in 128 countries (But that includes the Jaguar brand). The Land Cruiser has markets in 170 countries. By any definition it is a "global vehicle".
Correlation does not equal causation. But, yes, the Land Cruiser is a global vehicle, but not because it is sold in that many countries. It can be sold in that many countries BECAUSE it is a global vehicle.
Go back and read the engine parallel. It is the most easy explanation to understand.

Noted your above inclusion of the Prado models. However, what you posted is just showing the overview of available models over lifespan of the brand, but it's probably safe to assume the Prado is included in the sales numbers because of the Land Cruiser moniker even though they are outside the HD product line.
I know it's a side-discussion, but you can design something as a global vehicle/boat/engine/whatever, and not yet having any sales, and not yet having any sales channel abroad. It's about the design and how to make it a universal design that is intended to be sold anywhere.
 

Box Rocket

Well-known member
Oh brother. I'm going to go back to ignoring you after this response. You make up your own definitions, your own criteria and even your own numbers. So you can continue to exist in your land of make-believe.

But there isn't compared to other vehicles. What I said was that although the market is bigger in the US (it is), it is very much smaller than outside the IS:
That's not what you said. Go back and read. But it doesn't matter. You'll make up another excuse to support your baseless claim and everyone else will continue to ignore you.

Read the things I have posted in context. You failed to grasp the concept of a "global vehicle", and doubled down on that ignorance by mentioning how many people in Colorado drives Wranglers.
Seriously? From the previous IFS argument you took literally everything out of context and now you fault others for (in your perception) taking something out of context. I also never mentioned Colorado. I said cold climates. #hookedonphonics

It wasn't a try for anything. Although even in its home country, Wranglers doesn't sell to many people - especially not if we cut the Barbies, the Bros, and the rock crawlers (or wannabe rock crawlers.
False. Plain and simple. Wranglers sell in huge numbers to those buying 4wd vehicles. Nobody is comparing anything here to a Ford Focus or Toyota Corolla so stop trying to.


No, I'm not. Maybe there are other reasons why sales of the Land Cruiser might drop, you think?
That doesn't support your argument one way or the other. The new Defender is a global vehicle. The Wrangler is not.
Who ever said the Wrangler was a global vehicle? I sure didn't. Show me where anyone made that claim. You selectively discount anything anyone else says and make up things to support your own claims or definitions. I never said the sole reason the Land Cruiser was a global vehicle was because it was sold in more countries. There are many here with actual ability to comprehend what they read, and those people also understand that shared platform, engine options and other components across markets are what makes a vehicle a global vehicle. But go ahead, discount that and make up something else to say its wrong and you have all the answers. LOL.

:ignore-mode-on:
 

REDROVER

Explorer
haha wouldn’t it be awesome if the hardiest part was to drop the fuel tank ?

newer vehicles almost all European vehicles and Americans as well, come with direct injection pumps, 800 to 1200 psi

Those pumps are nightmare to replace,
Almost always special order, and at least 800 and up.
your are spoiled by awesome 80 series you don’t even know the disasterios direct injection pump issues haha
Yeah fuel pump is just one issue, they have so many nonsense sensors that can make someone stranded and parts are never available same day.
 

Pilat

Tossing ewoks on Titan
LOL. There are 195 countries in the world. Apparently NONE of the vehicles manufacturers are "global".

Done ........
Yeah, you're "done" alright: You really know how to flaunt what you don't know.

Just because no vehicle is sold in every country on earth, doesn't mean it is not a global vehicle. You can be a global company yet not have representation in every damn country on earth.
A global vehicle is a vehicle intended to be sold in all markets on the global marketplace. It shouldn't be so hard to fathom. An All-States/US-Wide engine means that it can also be sold in California which has some of the strictest rules in the US (and as it happens, in the world too). If that engine manufacturer wanted to sell it to China, Asia in general, Europe, South America, Canada, and so on, they would have to make sure it also met the rules in those markets. At that stage, if it can meet that order, it becomes a global engine.
The same is true with a vehicle.

With regards to "global design" (i.e. design only), the idea is it that a global design is a design that works across cultures in different parts of the world.

Edit: It's weird with you two: You are so gung-ho at trying to prove me wrong, you would protest gravity if I told you it existed. You would claim it was pixies holding everything down or some other fantasy.
 

REDROVER

Explorer
haha wouldn’t it be awesome if the hardiest part was to drop the fuel tank ?

newer vehicles almost all European vehicles and Americans as well, come with direct injection pumps, 800 to 1200 psi

Those pumps are nightmare to replace,
Almost always special order, and at least 800 and up.
your are spoiled by awesome 80 series you don’t even know the disasterios direct injection fuel pump issues haha
Yeah fuel pump is just one issue, they have so many nonsense sensors that can make someone stranded and parts are never available same day.
 
Last edited:

Box Rocket

Well-known member
haha wouldn’t it be awesome if the hardiest part was to drop the fuel tank ?

newer vehicles almost all European vehicles and Americans as well, come with direct injection pumps, 800 to 1200 psi

Those pumps are nightmare to replace,
Almost always special order, and at least 800 and up.
your are spoiled by awesome 80 series you don’t even know the disasterios direct injection pump issues haha
Yeah fuel pump is just one issue, they have so many nonsense sensors that can make someone stranded and parts are never available same day.
Good to know.
 

Pilat

Tossing ewoks on Titan
Oh brother. I'm going to go back to ignoring you after this response. You make up your own definitions, your own criteria and even your own numbers. So you can continue to exist in your land of make-believe.
No I don't. You lie again.


That's not what you said. Go back and read. But it doesn't matter. You'll make up another excuse to support your baseless claim and everyone else will continue to ignore you.

Too complex a scenario for you:
LOL, a "global vehicle" means a vehicle designed to be sold everywhere in the world without problems. Designed to thread the needle of various regulations. Not something that can mostly only be sold in the home market.
There is a reason the Wrangler doesn't sell much outside of its home market. It is unsafe to the extent that it is not allowed to be sold in all countries, and those that do allow, still doesn't see much sales. It being unsafe and basically aimed at 1) Wannabe Barbies, 2) Bros, and 3) Rock crawlers, means that there isn't even a big market in the US, but much bigger than there are in the rest of the world

So, yes, even though they sell quite a few cars in the US, the Wrangler - even as iconic as it is - is still not at the top. What was it last year? 250k? In the US?


Seriously? From the previous IFS argument you took literally everything out of context and now you fault others for (in your perception) taking something out of context. I also never mentioned Colorado. I said cold climates. #hookedonphonics

Read the bolded above (expand it). There is a context. The context is that even in the US - it's home market, they are not at the top of the sales - ESPECIALLY if we remove the barbies, the bros, and the rock crawlers (wannabe or real).
Countering your claims one by one is not taking things out of context. Countering claims while misrepresenting them by taking only a few words in a sentence that is qualified by the rest of the sentence is.
As for the Colorada comment - I went back and looked, and it Mpinco who mentioned Colorado. It is difficult to tell you two apart. You claim to be ignorant of the concept of a "global vehicle" and use the exact same arguments and turns of phrase.


False. Plain and simple. Wranglers sell in huge numbers to those buying 4wd vehicles.
See, you qualify your statements also. Now it's "those buying 4wd".
You, however, forget that that is only in the US - and even then some states takes way Wranglers than other states. Is the Wrangler even legal to sell in California without modifications?

Nobody is comparing anything here to a Ford Focus or Toyota Corolla so stop trying to.
We are talking about designing something as a "global vehicle" and that there is a difference between something mostly intended to sell only in the US and something designed to be sold all over the world.

Who ever said the Wrangler was a global vehicle? I sure didn't. Show me where anyone made that claim.
The Wrangler (or Jeep) was mentioned when you guys was talking about US sales and we were talking about a global vehicle. It is a great example of something that is not a global vehicle. But you still want to say it sells a lot in the US. Maybe (depending on how you define "a lot"), but you're still refusing to acknowledge the concept of a "global vehicle.


You selectively discount anything anyone else says and make up things to support your own claims or definitions.
Says the bloke who refuses to learn anything and make ******** up to support his claims.

I never said the sole reason the Land Cruiser was a global vehicle was because it was sold in more countries.

Oh, great, you now refuse to stand by what you said only a few posts ago:

Jaguar Land Rover has markets in 128 countries (But that includes the Jaguar brand). The Land Cruiser has markets in 170 countries. By any definition it is a "global vehicle".

Noted your above inclusion of the Prado models. However, what you posted is just showing the overview of available models over lifespan of the brand, but it's probably safe to assume the Prado is included in the sales numbers because of the Land Cruiser moniker even though they are outside the HD product line.

And this was after you repeatedly try to make-believe that such a thing as a global vehicle was about how much it sold etc.

There are many here with actual ability to comprehend what they read, and those people also understand that shared platform, engine options and other components across markets are what makes a vehicle a global vehicle.
You won't even stand by what you write. It is evident you still don't quite get the concept of a "global vehicle".

But go ahead, discount that and make up something else to say its wrong and you have all the answers. LOL.
Again: Coming from the guy who still haven't quite a grasp on what a "global vehicle is" as he has shown throughout this thread, it is evident that he is incapable of learning:

Here are your posts on this global vehicle "debate" where you obviously didn't understand it. My emphasis:

What does "global vehicle" have to do with it? Very few actually need a vehicle with global support. And there's something to be said for simplicity in the case of repairs needed in remote villages in many parts of the world for those to do travel beyond their own borders.
What does "global vehicle" have to do with it? Very few actually need a vehicle with global support. And there's something to be said for simplicity in the case of repairs needed in remote villages in many parts of the world for those to do travel beyond their own borders.

What would I do without you to share all this vast knowledge with me? LOL. First off, I'm well aware of what a global market vehicle is, since I drive one. I would submit that the Land Cruiser is a far more prevelant global vehicle than the LR. I'm not a Jeep fan but you really have no idea what the market demand for them is. You live somewhere where they are not common and therefore make assumptions out of ignorance. Quite the opposite of what your theory is I would say they are even more common in cold, winter climates in the US because of the 4WD system. And you apparently haven't paid attention to recent Jeep sales if you think there's not even a big market in the US. They are extremely popular and many dealers have a waiting list for the new Gladiators.
Uh, yeah you did.
you said, " means that there isn't even a big market in the US,"

So nice try. I don't know why you continue to post in this thread? Pretty sure everyone has concluded you don't know what you're talking about.

And global market vehicle.....are you saying the Land Cruiser isn't a global vehicle?
Here's some numbers for you...

Global sales for the Toyota Land Cruiser. Cumulatively since it's inception over 10 Million Land Cruisers have been sold. But let's talk more recently. 2013 showed ~400,000 Land Cruisers sold worldwide. 2014 saw 450,000 sold. 2018 was roughly 360,000 Land Cruisers sold. 2019 which isn't over yet has seen over 250,000 sold. See data here:
https://global.toyota/en/newsroom/toyota/29534066.html

Yeah it has dropped, but lets look at the Land Rover.....

in 2013 there were roughly 270,000 LR's sold worldwide across the entire product line. The Defender specifically saw just over 17,000 sold. The Discovery just shy of 46,000 sold. But even including the entire product line there were few sales by a large margin than the Land Cruiser in the same year. For 2018 across the same product line there was a total of roughly 241,000 LR's sold. Still over 100,000 short of Land Cruiser. If you add the Discovery Sport in for 2017 and 2018 as a new addition to the product line that number for 2018 it goes up to 336,000. Still short of the Land Cruiser. See Data here:
So sorry, don't insult yourself by claiming I don't know what a global vehicle is. Everyone knows that around the world the most widely used 4wd is a Toyota.

Exand the above one for the doosie at the bottom.

Jaguar Land Rover has markets in 128 countries (But that includes the Jaguar brand). The Land Cruiser has markets in 170 countries. By any definition it is a "global vehicle".

So, there you have it. It was all about how Jeep sells in the US, how the Land Cruisers sell more, and in more countries and so on. So, yes, you have shown yourself to not actually know what you're protesting. I can't believe the two of you balked at the concept of a "global vehicle", and refused to understand even after I explained it with the engines in the US.

:ignore-mode-on:
Yes, please do. Having to explain such basic concepts to dishonest people who refuse to even try to understand things gets a bit tiresome.
 
Last edited:

Box Rocket

Well-known member
Your responses sound like, "I know you are but what am I?" We get it. you are all knowledgeable and wise......but still zero experience. ;)
 

mpinco

Expedition Leader
.......Just because no vehicle is sold in every country on earth, doesn't mean it is not a global vehicle. .........

You have it backwards. A product is designed for the target market you intend to be successful in, nothing more. If it is 1 country, so be it. 128, so be it. More, depends on your goals, whether they are total sales or market penetration. Period. You can enter a market and withdraw from a market, irrespective of product design. You can sell global or local, design global or local or anywhere in the middle. I would say that you don't design for a market you do not intend on entering. You do no overdesign for obvious reasons.

The Luxury Defender may be 'global' by your definition but they are only marketed in 128 countries. Nothing more.
 

Pilat

Tossing ewoks on Titan
Your responses sound like, "I know you are but what am I?" We get it. you are all knowledgeable and wise......but still zero experience. ;)
I have shown you exactly where you lied. And I have explained to you where you were wrong so you could understand the concept. I have even gone to the length of quoting your posts so you can reread them and to show you you once again lied when you said it wasn't about how many were sold or how many countries it was sold in. That row of responses show exactly how dishonest you are.
Next you will tell me that those "vindicate you" like some other blowhard shown to be lying, or that if one counters you with fact, it's all about "I know you are, but what am I".

Aand, you even repost the lie that I can't possibly have any experience - even when you have been shown how wrong you were and have it documented in front of you.
But, please, do tell how your claimed "experience" somehow makes you less wrong in the above? Were you the tosser who wanted me to ship a vehicle over so we could have a bro-off? I think you were that guy. In your mind, that would somehow prove something. And if not, that would also prove something.
I am glad you know what you're talking as is evident from your postings where you show you don't even know the basics. Hell, you and mpinco can't even grasp a simple concept when it is spoon-fed you.
Although, to be fair, I think mpinco has a better grasp of the global vehicle concept at this point than you.
 

Pilat

Tossing ewoks on Titan
You have it backwards. A product is designed for the target market you intend to be successful in, nothing more. If it is 1 country, so be it. 128, so be it. More, depends on your goals, whether they are total sales or market penetration. Period. You can enter a market and withdraw from a market, irrespective of product design. You can sell global or local, design global or local or anywhere in the middle. I would say that you don't design for a market you do not intend on entering. You do no overdesign for obvious reasons.

Ah, I spoke too soon in the above post where I thought that you had a better grasp on the concept of a "global vehicle". Apparently you don't.
You can design a global vehicle and it's a global vehicle even before it is sold in a particular country. It means it CAN be sold there. Designing a US-wide, California legal engine, and your intentions may be to sell it there too. But it doesn't mean that if you don't get into that market (California in this case), that it is not California legal or "legal to sell in all states".

Of course you don't overdesign unless you have to. But LR needs to sell their cars in Europe, the US (including California), Canada and other countries with reasonably high standards all around (California is the state with the highest standards in the US), so they design to that. If they hit the targets of the most restricted rules and regulations, it can be sold anywhere. Hence a "global vehicle."
If I wanted to sell an engine worldwide for cars, the smart thing would be to make it a global engine: Make it meets rules and regulations - also planned ones in the foreseeable future and have them meet them in California, the EU (and various cities with extra strict rules), Canada, and so on. By doing that, I can sell it anywhere.
 

Pilat

Tossing ewoks on Titan
Found this:

The Land Rover Defender has been reborn as a mainstream model for the global market, taking heavy design and capability cues from the iconic original, which was withdrawn from sale in 2016, and the 2009-2016 Land Rover Discovery 4.

Crucially, to that end, the new Defender has been engineered to meet global car regulations, including the world’s two largest markets, China and the US, where it previously had negligible impact because of regulatory restrictions by the time production was halted. In total, it will now be sold in 128 territories.


From here:

 

Forum statistics

Threads
188,062
Messages
2,901,766
Members
229,415
Latest member
Gatofoamball
Top