Aren't there still militaries world wide that use these rigs? Wouldn't they still prefer the old fashioned solid axles?
When I was in Botswana last year, the Botswana Defense Force had only receive a partial shipment so far of their brand new Defender Puma's to replace their TDI fleet. They love them, and the Defender is perfectly suited to the African Bush and their military tasks.
I guess they might. Although the Humvee seems to do ok for our millitary with independent suspension.
The US HMMVW accomplishes it's capability with IFS by combining with portal axles and springs that are so stiff you'd lose your fillings if it's not loaded to GVWR. Think about how successful that design was (the H1) in trying to compete in the civilian sector at the same time. It is not an easy game to dual market to military, commercial and civilian on a broad scale for a single product. Beyond G-wagon, original Willys Jeep, Land Rover Series and Defender, and select Toyota Land Cruisers, I can't think of any other products that have been successful in all three sectors. I'm sure I'm missing one or two, but I'd have to do some research.
If you look at the situation logically... the Range Rover line has "sporting luxury" locked up all the way from $42k to $142k. It would not make sense for Defender to compete with any of these vehicles. The new line of Land Rovers will emphasize utility and usability, at a broad price point.
This statement quickly reminds me of after the initial launch and success of the JK, and in almost every circle, you can hear people asking each other "Why didn't jeep do a 4 door wrangler sooner?", with the response of "They probably didn't want to compete with the Cherokee." Everyone reading this has probably heard this from someone at some point. I think broadening the horizontal market has been proven by Jeep as a potentially successful strategy under the right conditions, that Land Rover should consider.
There was also an interview a few months back with the JLR design head (Gerry McGovern) who stated he wanted to take on the Toyota Hilux with the Defender. This comment would seem to compete in strategy with the middle ground strategy between the JK and the G Wagon. Be interesting to see how which direction they choose.
Unlike some other threads I've read in this particular forum, this thread is a fantastic dialogue with every point of view adding to discussion tremendously.