rickashay
Explorer
I debate the same thing. According to this calculator, your ideal gear ratio with 35's is just under 4.56- so 4.56 will have just about the same power as the stock gears with stock size tires. I think i'd want a little extra grunt if I was using my truck for what you're planning, and go with 4.88s.
We have highways with 85mph speeds limits around here, so I was thinking that with 4.56s, I wouldn't lose as much top end and it'd make those stretches a little more comfortable. But for everything else, I'd want 4.88s with 35s.
That's my concern also. I have to drive a minimum of 1.5-2.5 hours to get to any of my "local" wheeling locations. I also primarily decided to build my Tundra so I can do more long distance wheeling trips like Utah, Colorado, California, Baja, and Alaska. The 4.56 would be better for fuel economy and highway speeds.
Imo the gear ratio bring you back to what stock would be but it doesn't take in to consideration of all the weight added from the upsize. So imo it wouldn't feel like stock or am I over thinking it.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Here's the flip side.... the 4.88's would be nice for all the additional weight. Your right, the gear ratio corrects for your tire size but not all the extra beef being carried around in the truck. I will be driving my Tundra on 35's w/stock gears for a bit before I get my gears in. I will report with my findings and that will probably be what makes my decision. I'm not worried about the lower gears for crawling, as I plan to have a crawlbox in the next 2 years.
One point I will mention though is that I recently drove a fully built 97' LX450 with 4.88 gears and 35's. This truck was HEAVY with an RTT, beadlocks, and fully expo-ready. It was in my decision phase of selling my LX and I wanted to see what a re-gear would do for the powertrain. I must admit that I was somewhat disappointed. The truck rolled around the city way better with the 4.88's but was reving substantially higher on the highway and I felt I had to "try" harder to keep the truck rolling at 110 km/hr. With the stock 4.10's it was hard to climb to that speed but once there, it would kind of just roll along. A common misconception is that higher gearing gives you more grunt, but it absolutely does not. It simply changes the RPM or what speed your vehicle is in it's peak powerband. If I was DD'ing the truck and had to drive around the city, the lower gears would really help with getting the heavy beast rolling off the line, but if it's just a highway roller I dunno.... you live with slower acceleration for the long hours spent at highway speed or you live with high RPMs for the long hours at highways speeds while you have slightly better acceleration off the line.
My reasoning anyway... I'm leaning for the 4.56 if you couldn't already tell.