figure I'd join in.
I voted for the Comp 4x4 hinge. since I'm the only one who voted for it, I'll explain why I picked it over the other designs. (it took me a LONG time to decide on this hinge.)
first off, I'm not a fan of the bronze bushing type hinges. I built a bronze bushing hinge for my first tire carrier on my old 2003 TJ. It had over 150,000km on it before i sold it. I had to replace the bushings a few times because they ovaled out which allowed the tire carrier to move ALOT...
I picked the Comp 4x4 HD hinge. 1750lbs capacity. (whatever, capacity ratings on carrier hinges are useless.)
what really got my attention with this hinge is the sleeve. I really like the fact that I dont have to weld the spindle. I was however dissapointed with the Comp4x4 design, the spindle is held in the sleeve by a tiny little pin. This little pin is "supposed" to hold the spindle from moving up, down and side to side. yeah, I dont think so. so i did a couple mods to it for better strength and piece of mind.
I real liked the sleeve design, not only for strength and not having to weld the spindle but because I could easily remove the whole tire carrier without have to dismantle the hinge.
first, I got a large washer. Installed the spindle, put the pin in and then welded the large washer to the inside of the sleeve. This makes for a solid base for the spindle to rest on when the pin isn't installed.
second, I am going to be replacing the pin with a set screw. Since I welded the washer in the sleeve, I no longer need anything to hold the spindle from moving down. The set screw will be easier to install and remove than this pin.
third, I will be drilling and tapping the bottom of the spindle. This will allow me to put a bolt in through the washer i welded into the sleeve, to eliminate the spindle coming out of the sleeve in the event of a roll over.
That takes care of the sleeve to spindle issues I had.
Now, I know Double Shear is the way to go. Unfortunately you cant really go double shear with a trailer bearing type hinge if you want to keep the crap out of the bearing.
I am planning on machining a cap that not only protects and seals the bearings but also has provision for a double shear mount.
I am still in the build stage of the tire carrier and most of my design is still in my head. I have installed the sleeve and washer into my bumper.
I'll start a build thread when i get started on the rest.