Our Astro does almost everything better than our Syncro; it is way faster, quieter, more comfortable and much more (although not 100%) reliable. I consider the Astro to be a very fast moving appliance that can haul lots of stuff and tow a good sized load. With airbags... Herbie with the lifted 4WD poptop Astro is definitely on the right track.
While maintaining the Astro is a straight cost-vs-value proposition that will terminate with the Astro getting recycled the instant that ratio exceeds 1.0, I find myself going to illogical lengths to keep our Syncro going. If I'd had the Astro's transmission in/out 5 times in the last 3 months trying to get the rear main seal to hold, it would be gone. If I was looking at a multi-thousand dollar engine conversion just to make the Astro reliable & powerful enough to not be a rolling-roadblock, it would be gone.
]
Wow, I can't believe anyone could call that Astro van torture chamber comfortable?! I drove one for 45 minutes on friday and I still have a sore leg. The footwell on those things is even worse than on a Dodge van. Yes I have driven it quite a bit myself- at least fifteen or twenty thousand kilometers.
I spend a lot of time working on my mother's Safari, and while the engine may be bulletproof, I have replaced so much other stuff on that thing it's stupid. It's sad that such a great job of packaging could be so difficult to live with.
On the other hand, I've never owned a Westfalia, though I have borrowed an early 70's model. It felt like driving a house or a ship, not a car.:088: At least the Vanagon model drives better.
I am the satisfied owner of a couple of high mileage Jetta diesels, and I am always on the lookout for a cheap diesel Westfalia... Yes, I know they are slow. I've owned slow Volvo and Mercedes diesel cars -my Volvo 245 was so slow that the only car I
ever passed going uphill was a diesel Westfalia, and I was barely creeping past while trying not to gloat... I'm not really in a hurry when I'm travelling, so a diesel Westy would be just fine for me.
After the last go around replacing the steering column and ignition switch in mom's GMC, I finally realized the engineering in these vans is just too much on the cheap side for me to live with, and that I'm getting to old to put up with uncomfortable vehicles.