I’ve got a Diehard Platinum group 65 that I bought in Oct 2011, making it almost 12 years old. Not as impressive as you guys, but it’s in a summer trail rig. It’s never been on a charger or battery tender, not even once. I drive the rig a handful of times each summer, and just disconnect the battery when the vehicle is in storage, roughly Nov - Apr each year. It still performs flawlessly, even after months of slumbering.
I keep wondering the same thing - when do I decide I’ve got my money’s worth and just replace it so it doesn’t leave me stranded somewhere? In fact, that’s exactly what I did on the Tacoma - about 12 years on a Diehard Platinum group 31, and I finally just replaced it last summer because we were going on a 2 week, 3000 mile trip, and I didn’t want to risk it. I did notice the new battery gave me faster cranking, but the Platinum was still completely functional when I replaced it.