Interesting stuff Brian, makes more sense I guess. I just wonder about the future of PPA with the way the market is going, you really can not teach a person how to become brilliant at seeing, either you have it or you don't. Digital wonder-cams, workshops, photoshop, they can not give you a great eye, you have to have it inherently to a degree and then it can be honed.
Case in point, a friend of mine works in weddings based out of Southern California. He has a photojournalism background, not a member of PPA. He totally buries most of is competition in terms of raw talent, so he gets anywhere from $8,500-$21,000 per wedding, shoots a fair amount of film as well to give his clients something different in terms of medium.
I shoot a lot of landscapes, taught a couple of workshops a few years back but found that all people wanted to do is copy my work, find out how I make my living, who my clients are, where my favorite spots were, so I bailed on it. I find I do better income wise without teaching workshops because I keep shooting, keep in the field, keep getting better at what I do. But the big increase in income in fine art ( before the crash ) came when I ditched digital for fine art work. I now hand print from 6x6 black and white negs in a real darkroom. These prints fetch at least 4 times if not more than computer generated prints. And this is a trend that is emerging more and more as people get tired of paying for what is essentially computer art, most galleries echo this sentiment. Real is the new fake, the old thing is now new again...
Personally I think that with online photo communities like Flickr and others, group workshop settings are going to go the way of the dinosaur. I mean, who is going to want to pay thousands of dollars to go out to the same location everyone else goes out to with half a dozen photographers getting the same shot? If I were a newcomer to photography and wanted to really get something out of a workshop, I would hire a really well known shooter to do a one on one in an exotic local. If you are going to pay a couple grand for a group workshop, why not pay double that and get something really unique?
Photography has changed a lot in some ways, then not at all in others. You still have to have loads of talent to really make it anywhere, no digital camera, no workshop and no organization will change this....ever.
By the way, I am not trying to give you grief, just put things in perspective in terms of what goes on in the craft across the entire spectrum. Just get out and enjoy without worrying about the destination, for the journey is over before you know it..