Here are a few of the new subcompact 4x4 vehicles for sale in USA for 2011. If you think of more subcompact examples, let us know.
2012 Nissan Juke
1.6-liter Direct Injection turbocharged 4-cylinder engine
188 hp, 177 lb-ft
continuously variable transmission with sport mode
full time all-wheel drive w/ torque vectoring
independent rear suspension
EPA 25/30 mpg
~$21,000
I saw a Juke on the road the other day. Its appearance is definitely unusual, but its size makes its exaggerated styling cues appear almost cute. The torque vectoring transmission makes the Juke the best handling subcompact SUV.
2011 Subaru Impreza Outback Sport
2.5-liter 4-cylinder engine
170 hp, 174 lb-ft
5 speed manual transmission
full time all wheel drive
independent rear suspension
EPA 20/27 mpg
~$21,000
Four doors and Subaru reliability are pluses for the Impreza
Suzuki SX4 Crossover
2.0-liter 4-cylinder engine
150 hp, 140 lb-ft
6 speed manual
FWD or full time all wheel drive
twist beam rear suspension
EPA 22/30 mpg
~$19,000
The SX4 Crossover is considerably lighter than the vehicles above, which helps reduce the impact of its lack of torque. It's nice to be able to run in front wheel drive when conditions don't require AWD.
The Jeep Patriot is considered a compact car. But since it's less expensive than the subcompacts above, the Patriot deserves a look
Jeep Patriot Sport X 4x4
2.4L 4 -cylinder engine
5 speed manual transmission
part time 4x4
solid rear axle
EPA 22/28 mpg
~$18,000
Add $2000 to the price of the Patriot to get their CVT automatic transmission with extra-low first gear, plus a package of off-road oriented accessories that include an engine oil cooler, fuel tank skid plate, hill descent control, and AT tires.