The local clubs we have around here did not seem to want people who would not make HAM a lifestyle having any part of operating a radio.
This has been my experience as well, unfortunately.
Here's how I look at it: I have a busy life. I have a lot of irons in the fire. Work, family, and my hobbies and interests. Among those hobbies are off-roading, camping (not neccessarily off-road), motorcycle riding, shooting, hunting and fishing. I also have a house and several vehicles that need maintenance, and a wife who has hobbies that she expects me to support just as she supports mine.
I simply don't have the time/energy/desire to adopt another hobby. What I want in a radio is simple: Push the button, talk, and have the other person hear me, and me hear them. That's what I need and that's
ALL I need.
Talking around the world, communicating with a satellite, bouncing a signal off the moon - I don't have the slightest desire to do any of those things.
To me, the biggest problem with HAM is that the radios are made for
enthusiasts, which is to say, gadget geeks. So they are packed with a bewildering array of features features that make it difficult for a casual user to operate. And honestly, I think a lot of HAMs
like it that way. They
like having this hobby to themselves and they have no desire in a radio that's simple to understand and operate. And since HAMs are the only ones who are buying amateur radios, the manufacturers have no reason to make "simple to operate" HAM radios.
I think the mindset that amateur radio needs to be exclusive and snooty will just lead to its irrelevance, which would be a great loss. So I don't mind just as long as people are willing to put in some minimal effort to understand and be good operators. Most of the guys get fed up with me, I tend to be tangential (I'm an Extra and an EE), but I just like talking about radios.
But there's the rub, Dave: There's no reason for someone to put "extra effort" into communications when there is an option that meets his needs
without requiring "extra effort." "Effort" - like time and money - is a zero-sum game. The effort a person spends on setting up a radio is effort he could be spending on something that interests him more.
And I agree that the exclusive nature of Amateur Radio will lead to its irrelevance - there are some that say it already has (like these guys:
http://www.hamsexy.com.) The problem is, there are a lot of folks within the amateur community who
like the exclusive/snooty nature and who will fight tooth and nail against it (the way they fought against dropping the CW requirement, for example.) Like any other hobbyist (even those of us with 4x4s) there are a lot of folks within the hobby who are jealous of preserving it for the dedicated few, and with the license requirement as a gateway, I don't see that changing any time soon.
Bottom line is that at the present time, for most casual off-roaders
within the US (and maybe Canada, but I can't speak to that), CB is the most practical 2-way communications option. Yes, it has its drawbacks, but so do the other options and the "universality" of CB is its biggest advantage, because the best radio in the world is a paper weight if there's nobody on the other end to talk to. :ylsmoke: