You'll all love this... I talked with a MAJOR tire manufacturer at SEMA (NOT BFG!) about the new BFG A/T. They've had a few set through benchmark testing now... I mentioned that the old BFG tread left a LOT to be desired in ice/packed/wet performance compared any modern tire. The engineer that I was talking to responded by saying that the NEW BFG AT was THE BEST non-studded/non dedicated winter tire that they had ever tested on ice.
Sounds like BFG finally brought the A/T back to the front of the pack!! He did indicate that it is possible they've compromised something else about the tire (treadwear, cut/chip resistance, etc) but could say without doubt that the winter performance was top notch!!
Keep the long term feedback coming in!!
Chris